Where Is the Evidence? Looking Back to Jeanne Chall and Enduring Debates About the Science of Reading
- 20 April 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Reading Research Quarterly
- Vol. 56 (S1) , S157-S169
Abstract
In this historical analysis, we examine the context of debates over the role of phonics in literacy and current debates about the science of reading, with a focus on the work and impact of the late literacy scholar Jeanne Chall. We open by briefly tracing the roots of the enduring debates from the 19th and 20th centuries, focusing on beginning reading, decoding, and phonics. Next, we explore insights drawn from the whole language movement as understood by Kenneth Goodman and Yetta Goodman, as well as a synthesis of key ideas from Chall’s critique of the whole language approach. We then analyze the shifts across the three editions of Chall’sLearning to Read: The Great Debateand summarize major ideas from her body of work, such as the stage model of reading development. We suggest that reading instruction should be informed by a broader historical lens in looking at the “science of reading” debates and should draw on a developmental stage model to teaching reading, such as the six‐stage model provided by Chall. We describe implications for educators, textbook publishers, researchers, and policymakers that address the current reading debates, and provide considerations of what Chall might say about learning to read in a digital era given the pressures on teacher educators and teachers to align their practice with what is deemed to be the science of reading.Keywords
Funding Information
- Harvard University
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Review of Research on Universal Design Educational ModelsRemedial and Special Education, 2014
- Designing for DiversityJournal of Literacy Research, 2011
- Why Elementary Teachers Might Be Inadequately Prepared to Teach ReadingJournal of Learning Disabilities, 2009
- Universal Design for Learning: meeting the challenge of individual learning differences through a neurocognitive perspectiveUniversal Access in the Information Society, 2007
- Constructing 21st-Century Teacher EducationJournal of Teacher Education, 2006
- Media, Information Communication Technologies, and Youth LiteraciesAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 2004
- The Reading WarsEducational Policy, 2004
- The Impact of Sesame Street on Preschool Children: A Review and Synthesis of 30 Years' ResearchMedia Psychology, 1999
- Roots of the Whole-Language MovementThe Elementary School Journal, 1989
- Reading: A psycholinguistic guessing gameJournal of the Reading Specialist, 1967