As attention to social, cultural and physical diversities among student populations is steadily increasing in elementary/primary classrooms, the way in which teaching about those diversities is done necessitates a critical discussion. As most of the research on teachers’ responses to classroom diversity is conducted in big‐city, multicultural settings, this article departs from the norm by examining perspectives of teachers in a predominantly white community with mostly white students. The authors locate their exploratory research project in a Northern Ontario city and, using qualitative methods, consider the impact of teachers’ understandings of their own and students’ identities on their approaches to diversity. For these teachers to incorporate a diversity‐related topic into their teaching requires them to label it as an issue, which in turn is usually related to the presence or absence of certain identities in the classroom. The teachers struggle with the same/different conundrum and frequently turn their pedagogical dilemmas into pedagogical silences.