Wh-in-Situ Does Not Correlate with Wh-Indefinites or Question Particles
Author:
- 1 January 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MIT Press in Linguistic Inquiry
- Vol. 38 (1) , 139-166
Abstract
Two theories, the Clausal Typing Hypothesis (Cheng 1991) and the unselective binding theory of wh-in-situ, have linked wh-in-situ to two other phenomena typologically: the use of a question particle, and the use of wh-words as indefinites. This article shows, through a typological survey and a detailed comparison of Passamaquoddy and Mandarin Chinese, that there is no connection between wh-in-situ and either property. Passamaquoddy uses wh-words as indefinites in all the contexts Chinese does, but it is a robust wh-movement language. Crosslinguistically, languages of all possible types are attested: most crucially, wh-in-situ languages without question particles exist, and wh-in-situ languages that do not use wh-words as indefinites also exist. In fact, most languages, regardless of whether they are wh-movement or wh-in-situ languages, have question particles, and most languages use wh-words as indefinites.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Two Types of Wh-Scope Marking in PassamaquoddyNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 2004
- Questions and Question‐word Incorporating Quantifiers in MalayalamSyntax, 2001
- The Typology of Wh‐Movement, Wh‐Questions in MalaySyntax, 1998
- Two types of donkey sentencesNatural Language Semantics, 1996
- On nominal islands and LF extraction in ChineseNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 1994
- Indefinite Wh in Mandarin ChineseJournal of East Asian Linguistics, 1992
- The Greenbergian Word Order CorrelationsLanguage, 1992
- The Greenbergian word order correlationsLanguage, 1992
- Head-marking and dependent-marking grammarLanguage, 1986
- Syntax and semantics of questionsLinguistics and Philosophy, 1977