Asking the right questions in the right way: the need for a shift in research on psychological treatments for addiction
Author:
Abstract
Aim To identify possible reasons for the disappointingly negative results of methodologically rigorous controlled trials of psychological treatments in the addictions field.Method A selective overview of the literature on addictive behaviour change.Findings Eight failings of existing research are described: failing to account for the outcome equivalence paradox; neglecting relationships in favour of techniques; failing to integrate treatment research and research on unaided change; imposing an inappropriate time‐scale on the change process; failing to take a systems or social network view; ignoring therapists' tacit theories; not including the patient's view; and displaying an ignorance of modern developments in the philosophy of science.Conclusion Treatment research has been asking the wrong questions in the wrong way. Three necessary shifts in ways of conducting research are proposed: (i) the field should stop studying named techniques and focus instead on change processes; (ii) change processes should be studied within the broader, longer‐acting systems of which treatment is part; and (iii) science in the field should be brought up to date by acknowledging a variety of sources of useful knowledge.Keywords
This publication has 90 references indexed in Scilit:
- A vision of the next generation of behavioral therapies research in the addictions*Addiction, 2007
- Spaces of sobriety/sites of power: Examining social model alcohol recovery programs as therapeutic landscapesSocial Science & Medicine, 2006
- Acceptance and relationship context: a model of substance use disorder treatment outcomeAddiction, 2006
- Why people enter treatment for alcohol problems: Findings from UK Alcohol Treatment Trial pre‐treatment interviewsJournal of Substance Use, 2006
- Contingency management treatments that reinforce completion of goal-related activities: Participation in family activities and its association with outcomesDrug and Alcohol Dependence, 2005
- The Role of Religion and Spirituality in Recovery from Drink Problems: A Qualititative Study of Alcoholics Anonymous Members and South Asian MenAddiction Research & Theory, 2002
- The researcher's own therapy allegiances: A "wild card" in comparisons of treatment efficacy.Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 1999
- Therapist Effects in Three Treatments for Alcohol ProblemsPsychotherapy Research, 1998
- Paths to Recovery from Substance Misuse: Change of Lifestyle and the Role of TreatmentSubstance Use & Misuse, 1996
- Dropouts and continuers in Gamblers Anonymous: Life-context and other factorsJournal of Gambling Studies, 1986