Discrimination, Complexity, and the Public/Private Sector Question
- 12 October 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Work and Occupations
- Vol. 37 (4) , 435-475
Abstract
Does employment discrimination vary in degree or character across public and private labor market sectors? Prior research cannot fully address this question because it typically relies on one dimension of discrimination—estimates of wage gaps. This study extends the literature by analyzing 11,528 legally verified cases of race and sex discrimination from the Ohio Civil Rights Commission (1986-2003). Quantitative analyses demonstrate that aggregate rates of verified discrimination vary little by sector, yet there are elevated rates of public sector promotion discrimination and elevated rates of private sector firing discrimination. In-depth qualitative analyses show that specific sectoral processes contribute to these aggregate patterns. In the public sector, limited accountability for promotion decisions allows managers to devalue seniority, augment “soft skills,” and sabotage multiple stages of formalized proceedings. Moreover, the very devices intended to curb discriminatory promotion may inadvertently multiply the stages for bias to enter decisions. In the private sector, managers exploit the latitude afforded by the employment-at-will doctrine to differentially terminate workers, sometimes justifying their actions as cost saving in a competitive market. The author argues that these processes are in line with statistical discrimination and social closure theories and concludes by discussing their implications for understandings of workplace inequality.Keywords
This publication has 85 references indexed in Scilit:
- Gender and Discretionary Work EffortWork and Occupations, 2010
- Precarious Work, Insecure Workers: Employment Relations in TransitionAmerican Sociological Review, 2009
- Bayesian Bigot? Statistical Discrimination, Stereotypes, and Employer Decision MakingThe Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 2009
- Employment Laws and the Public Sector Employer: Lessons to Be Learned from a Review of Lawsuits Filed against Local GovernmentsPublic Administration Review, 2008
- Age Discrimination, Social Closure and EmploymentSocial Forces, 2007
- Rediscovering the Color Line within Work OrganizationsWork and Occupations, 2003
- Pregnancy Discrimination Litigation: Legal Erosion of Capitalist Ideology Under Equal Employment Opportunity LawSocial Forces, 1996
- Managerial Promotions in the Public SectorWork and Occupations, 1990
- Men and Women at Work: Sex Segregation and Statistical DiscriminationAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1986
- Indirect Institutionalized DiscriminationAmerican Politics Quarterly, 1977