A case for feedback and monitoring assessment in competency‐based medical education

Authors:

Abstract
Purpose Within competency‐based medical education, self‐regulated learning (SRL) requires residents to leverage self‐assessment and faculty feedback. We sought to investigate the potential for competency‐based assessments to foster SRL by quantifying the relationship between faculty feedback and entrustment ratings as well as the congruence between faculty assessment and resident self‐assessment. Materials and methods We collected comments in (a) an emergency medicine objective structured clinical examination group (objective structured clinical examinations [OSCE] and emergency medicine OSCE group [EMOG]) and (b) a first‐year resident multidisciplinary resuscitation “Nightmares” course assessment group (NCAG) and OSCE group (NOG). We assessed comments across five domains including Initial Assessment (IA), Diagnostic Action (DA), Therapeutic Action (TA), Communication (COM), and entrustment. Analyses included structured qualitative coding and (non)parametric and descriptive analyses. Results In the EMOG, faculty's positive comments in the entrustment domain corresponded to lower entrustment score Mean Ranks (MRs) for IA (17.6). In the NCAG, faculty's positive IA comments were negatively correlated with entrustment scores (ρ = −.27, P = .04). Across programs, faculty and residents made similar domain‐specific comments 13% of the time. Conclusions Minimal and inconsistent associations were found between narrative and numerical feedback. Performance monitoring accuracy and feedback should be included in assessment validation.
Funding Information
  • Southeastern Ontario Academic Medical Organization Innovation Fund
  • The Kingston Resuscitation Institute
  • The University of Saskatchewan College of Medicine

This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit: