The top-down approach to measurement uncertainty
Open Access
- 14 June 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Croatian Society for Medical Biochemistry and Laboratory Medicine in Biochemia Medica
- Vol. 30 (2) , 187-195
Abstract
Introduction: By quantifying the measurement uncertainty (MU), both the laboratory and the physician can have an objective estimate of the results’ quality. There is significant flexibility on how to determine the MU in laboratory medicine and different approaches have been proposed by Nordtest, Eurolab and Cofrac to obtain the data and apply them in formulas. The purpose of this study is to compare three different top-down approaches for the estimation of the MU and to suggest which of these approaches could be the most suitable choice for routine use in clinical laboratories. Materials and methods: Imprecision and bias of the methods were considered as components of the MU. The bias was obtained from certified reference calibrators (CRC), proficiency tests (PT), and inter-laboratory internal quality control scheme (IQCS) programs. The bias uncertainty, the combined and the expanded uncertainty were estimated using the Nordtest, Eurolab and Cofrac approaches. Results: Using different approaches, the expanded uncertainty estimates ranged from 18.9-40.4%, 18.2-22.8%, 9.3-20.9%, and 7.1-18.6% for cancer antigen (CA) 19-9, testosterone, alkaline phosphatase (ALP), and creatinine, respectively. Permissible values for MU and total error ranged from 16.0-46.1%, 13.1-21.6%, 10.7-26.2%, and 7.5-17.3%, respectively. Conclusion: The bias was highest using PT, followed by CRC and IQCS data, which were similar. The Cofrac approach showed the highest uncertainties, followed by Eurolab and Nordtest. However, the Eurolab approach requires additional measurements to obtain uncertainty data. In summary, the Nordtest approach using IQCS data was therefore found to be the most practical formula.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Different top-down approaches to estimate measurement uncertainty of whole blood tacrolimus mass concentration valuesClinical Biochemistry, 2018
- Measurement uncertainty: Friend or foe?Clinical Biochemistry, 2018
- Uncertainty in measurement and total error: different roads to the same quality destination?Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM), 2018
- Criteria for using proficiency test results for estimation of measurement uncertainty: feed analysis exampleAccreditation and Quality Assurance, 2017
- Uncertainty in measurement and total error – are they so incompatible?Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM), 2016
- Performance criteria for combined uncertainty budget in the implementation of metrological traceabilityClinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM), 2015
- Comparison between bottom-up and top-down approaches in the estimation of measurement uncertaintyClinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM), 2015
- Routine internal- and external-quality control data in clinical laboratories for estimating measurement and diagnostic uncertainty using GUM principlesScandinavian Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigation, 2012
- Comparison of ISO-GUM and Monte Carlo methods for the evaluation of measurement uncertainty: Application to direct cadmium measurement in water by GFAASTalanta, 2011
- Comparison of methods for the estimation of measurement uncertainty for an analytical method for sulphonamidesFood Additives & Contaminants: Part A, 2008