Quantitative phase microscopies: accuracy comparison
Preprint
Abstract
This article presents a thorough comparison of themain QPM techniques, focusing on their accuracy in terms of measurement precision and trueness. We focus on 8 techniques, namely digital holographic microscopy (DHM), cross-grating wavefront microscopy (CGM), which is based on QLSI (quadriwave lateral shearing interferometry), diffraction phase microscopy (DPM), differential phase-contrast (DPC) microscopy, phase-shifting interferometry (PSI) imaging, Fourier phase microscopy (FPM), spatial light interference microscopy (SLIM), and transport-of-intensity equation (TIE) imaging. For this purpose, we used a home-made numerical toolbox based on discrete dipole approximation (IF-DDA). This toolbox is designed to compute the electromagnetic field at the sample plane of a microscope, irrespective of the object's complexity or the illumination conditions. We upgraded this toolbox to enable it to model any type of QPM, and to take into account shot noise. In a nutshell, the results show that DHM and PSI are inherently free from artefacts and rather suffer from coherent noise; In CGM, DPC, DPM and TIE, there is a trade off between precision and trueness, which can be balanced by varying one experimental parameter; FPM and SLIM suffer from inherent artefacts that cannot be discarded experimentally in most cases, making the techniques not quantitative especially for large objects covering a large part of the field of view, such as eukaryotic cells.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dry mass photometry of single bacteria using quantitative wavefront microscopyBiophysical Journal, 2023
- Single-Shot Light-Field Microscopy: An Emerging Tool for 3D Biomedical ImagingBioChip Journal, 2022
- Cross-grating phase microscopy (CGM): In silico experiment (insilex) algorithm, noise and accuracyOptics Communications, 2022
- Local Surface Chemistry Dynamically Monitored by Quantitative Phase MicroscopySmall Methods, 2021
- Transport of intensity equation: a tutorialOptics and Lasers in Engineering, 2020
- Integration of diffraction phase microscopy and Raman imaging for label‐free morpho‐molecular assessment of live cellsJournal of Biophotonics, 2018
- Optical excitation and detection of neuronal activityJournal of Biophotonics, 2018
- Quantitative retardance imaging by means of quadri-wave lateral shearing interferometry for label-free fiber imaging in tissuesOptics Communications, 2018
- Fast Label-Free Cytoskeletal Network Imaging in Living Mammalian CellsBiophysical Journal, 2014
- Rapid, Massively Parallel Single-Cell Drug Response Measurements via Live Cell InterferometryBiophysical Journal, 2011