Comparative Evaluation of Solvers for Overcurrent Relay Setting
Open Access
- 15 April 2026
- journal article
- Published by Universidad Nacional de Colombia in Simposio Internacional sobre la Calidad de la Energía Eléctrica - SICEL
- Vol. 12 (1)
Abstract
The coordination of inverse-time overcurrent protection relays (51 relays) requires careful consideration to achieve an appropriate balance of selectivity, speed, and reliability when the system is subjected to faults. This study presents an evaluation of optimization algorithms using both linear and nonlinear programming methods available in Python’s SciPy library. The setting parameters considered are the Time Dial Setting (TDS), Pickup Setting (PS), and Time-Current Characteristic (TCC) curves, which must be efficiently configured. Several solvers were analyzed, including: highs, highs-ds, highs-ipm, simplex, revised simplex, interior-point, COBYLA, SLSQP, and trust-constr. Each was evaluated based on three criteria: relay operating time, sensitivity to fault current, and computational efficiency. The results indicate that the differences in total solver execution times are minimal, on the order of 1×10⁻⁷ seconds. However, highs-ipm and COBYLA demonstrated superior performance in terms of both speed and accuracy. Moreover, the inclusion of multiple setting parameters significantly enhances the overall effectiveness of the protection system. The study concludes that the optimal solver choice depends on the trade-off between computational time and solution accuracy. This research lays a strong foundation for future work involving the application of linear and nonlinear programming techniques in relay protection settings.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exponential-based dynamic objective function for coordination of overcurrent relays in power networksExpert Systems with Applications, 2024
- Optimization based control of overcurrent relays in distribution network considering real-time measurements: A case studyApplied Energy, 2024
- Impact of Different Types of Distributed Sources on Protection Coordination on Distribution Grid2024
- Optimal coordination of overcurrent relays in microgrids using meta-heuristic algorithms NSGA-II and harmony searchSustainable Computing: Informatics and Systems, 2024
- Relay Coordination Algorithm with Limits on Minimum Operating Time of customized Time Inverse Relays Characteristics2021
- Use of IEC 61850 to increase the security of the protection system2021
- Optimization of Overcurrent Relay Coordination using Artificial Bee Colony2021
- Highly sensitive microgrid protection using overcurrent relays with a novel relay characteristicIET Renewable Power Generation, 2020
- Optimal Overcurrent Relay Coordination: A ReviewProcedia Engineering, 2013
- Comparative study of heuristics for reliability optimization of complex systems2010