Classifying Unsafe Health and Care Behaviors in the Context of Just Culture: A Comparative Video-Based Vignette Study
Authors:
- Susana LorenzoSusana Lorenzo
- Eva Gil-HernándezEGEva Gil-Hernández
- Irene CarrilloIrene Carrillo
- Cristina NavarroCNCristina Navarro
- Pedro Lozano GagoPGPedro Lozano Gago
- Marta Macías MarotoMMMarta Macías Maroto
- Elvira Eva Moreno CampoyECElvira Eva Moreno Campoy
- Paloma Trillo LópezPLPaloma Trillo López
- Elena Corpas NogalesENElena Corpas Nogales
- Ángel Cobos-VargasÁCÁngel Cobos-Vargas
- Mª Del Carmen Jiménez EstradaMEMª Del Carmen Jiménez Estrada
- Pastora Pérez-PérezPPPastora Pérez-Pérez
Open Access
- 2 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Healthcare
- Vol. 14 (19) , 3275
Abstract
Background: Just Culture requires organizations to distinguish human mistakes from unsafe behavior while maintaining transparency, accountability and trust. However, little is known about how different stakeholders interpret these boundaries in realistic healthcare situations. This study aimed to explore how unsafe healthcare behaviors are classified by professionals and community and public-opinion stakeholders within the framework of Just Culture. Methods: This structured judgment study used standardized video vignettes across primary care, hospital, and nursing home settings. A purposive and convenience sample of 449 healthcare professionals, managers, and community/public representatives classified behaviors as honest error, at-risk behavior, or reckless behavior and provided written justifications. Concordance with a prespecified study-defined reference classification was examined using mixed-effects logistic regression. Results: Across 2976 classification opportunities, 2610 were analyzable within the three predefined categories. At-risk behavior was most frequent (40.5%), followed by honest error (33.5%) and reckless behavior (25.9%). Exact concordance with the prespecified reference classification was 48.4% and was highest for reckless behavior (67.4%). Participants’ justifications for their classification choices centered on intention, contextual pressure, foreseeability, omitted safety barriers, professional duty, and relational expectations. Conclusions: Participants generally distinguished human fallibility from the omission of available safeguards, but many behaviors were located in an intermediate zone of at-risk conduct rather than clear error or recklessness. The observed variability in interpreting error, risk, and responsibility, particularly around at-risk behavior, may be relevant to the implementation of Just Culture.Keywords
Funding Information
- the Instituto de Salud Carlos III (INT25/00003)
- the Instituto de Salud Carlos III (FI22/00277)
- Instituto de Salud Carlos III (PI24/00243)
- Instituto de Salud Carlos III (PI24/00376)
- Instituto de Salud Carlos III (PI24/00901)
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Studying social representations of cross-boundary collaboration between managers through drawingsEuropean Management Journal, 2023
- Understanding Honest Mistakes, Second Victims and Just Culture for Patient SafetyJournal of Healthcare Quality Research, 2023
- Gender Bias in Risk Management Reports Involving Physicians in Training – A Retrospective Qualitative StudyJournal of Surgical Education, 2022
- Integrating Principles of Safety Culture and Just Culture Into Nursing Homes: Lessons From the PandemicJournal of the American Medical Directors Association, 2021
- Why Accountability Sharing in Health Care Organizational Cultures Means Patients Are Probably SaferAMA Journal of Ethics, 2020
- The Anthropological and Ethnographic Approaches to Social Representations Theory – an Empirical Meta-Theoretical AnalysisIntegrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 2020
- The normalization of deviance in healthcare deliveryBusiness Horizons, 2010
- Errors in medicineClinica Chimica Acta, 2009
- The Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studiesJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2008
- Error in MedicineJAMA, 1994