Superior versus Anteroinferior Plating of the Clavicle: A Finite Element Study
Authors:
- Philippe FavrePFPhilippe Favre
- Peter KloenPKPeter Kloen
- David L HelfetDHDavid L Helfet
- Clément M L WernerCWClément M L Werner
- 1 November 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma
- Vol. 25 (11) , 661-665
Abstract
Objectives: Fixation plate positioning remains controversial in clavicle fracture reconstruction. Biomechanical studies favor a superior plate placement and clinical series report very low mechanical complications for anteroinferior plate placement. To clarify this apparent discrepancy, a biomechanical finite element analysis of the deformation mode, stress patterns, and peak stresses involved with superior and anteroinferior clavicle plate fixation was performed. Methods: Finite element models of the superior and anteroinferior reconstructions were built and the results were compared with those of the intact clavicle when loaded in axial compression and cantilever bending. Results: Superior plate placement was less likely to fail in axial compression but the anteroinferior plate placement was less likely to fail in cantilever bending. For all placements and loading modes, the region near the fracture gap experienced the highest stresses and was consequently critical for the behavior of the whole construct. The anteroinferior placement led to a deformation mode similar to the intact clavicle in both loading configurations, whereas the deformation mode with the superior placement was non-physiological. Conclusions: Anterorinferior plating is generally preferable, because it induces deformation modes similar to the intact clavicle and is less likely to fail during normal physiological loading (cantilever bending). Superior placement of the reconstruction plate may be recommended for a patient with a high risk of shoulder impacts (axial compression). Design improvements in the bridging area of the plate and special attention to obtain a good fixation around the fracture could reduce plate failures and provide a stiffer construcKeywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Failure of superior locking clavicle plate by axial pull-out of the lateral screws: A report of four casesJournal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery, 2009
- Biomechanical Evaluation of Clavicle Fracture Plating Techniques: Does a Locking Plate Provide Improved Stability?Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 2008
- Pedicled Vascularized Rib Transfer for Reconstruction of Clavicle Nonunions with Bony Defects: Anatomical and Biomechanical ConsiderationsPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2007
- Anterior-inferior Plate Fixation of Middle-third Fractures and Nonunions of the ClavicleJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 2006
- Buttressing angle of the double-plating fixation of a distal radius fracture: a finite element studyMedical & Biological Engineering & Computing, 2006
- Treatment of Acute Midshaft Clavicle Fractures: Systematic Review of 2144 FracturesJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 2005
- The aetiology and epidemiology of clavicular fracturesInjury, 2000
- Geometric properties and the predicted mechanical behavior of adult human claviclesJournal of Biomechanics, 1993
- Geometry parameters for musculoskeletal modelling of the shoulder systemJournal of Biomechanics, 1992
- Zur Biomechanik der menschlichen ClaviculaZeitschrift für Orthopädie und ihre Grenzgebiete, 1980