Small Renal Mass

Authors:
  • SCSteven C Campbell
    Steven C Campbell
  • MFMartha Faraday
    Martha Faraday
  • RURobert G Uzzo
    Robert G Uzzo

Abstract
As Gill and colleagues note in their Clinical Practice article (Feb. 18 issue),1 the topic of a small renal mass was recently addressed by a Guidelines Panel commissioned by the American Urological Association.2,3 However, we disagree with the contention that these guidelines are based “mostly on expert opinion.” The panel derived these guidelines after a systematic review of the literature and performance of a meta-analysis. The guidelines emphasize the peril, overuse, and short-term appeal of laparoscopic radical nephrectomy at the cost of future sequelae of chronic kidney disease, including increased rates of cardiovascular events, hospitalization, and death.2,4,5 Our meta-analysis also showed significantly increased rates of local recurrence with thermal ablation (P3 a particular concern for a cancer that lacks curative systemic therapies. We therefore take exception to the implications in the algorithm set forward by Gill and colleagues, which advocates thermal ablation for young, healthy patients for whom partial nephrectomy would be technically difficult.