Abstract
In many jurisdictions, the scope and sophistication of environmental regulations have increased dramatically since the 1970s and yet environmental degradation continues to worsen. This phenomenon is particularly acute in the mining industry where reclamation is increasingly regulated, but abandonment with limited reclamation remains the most common form of closure. Insufficient regulations, however, remain a prominent explanation for reclamation failure. This study, focused on the Yukon Territory, Canada, questions whether inadequate legislation and policy alone can explain continued reclamation failure and explores other possible explanations. We used discourse and content analysis to examine the reclamation promises, activities, and outcomes at three Yukon quartz (hard rock) mines from 1998-2024. We found that reclamation failure was co-produced through a consistent process of bureaucratic slippage: companies used discursive tactics to avoid reclamation requirements and regulators allowed the seemingly minor deviations without material consequences. As instances of bureaucratic slippage accumulated, regulatory implementation was weakened and regulatory capture occurred. We argue regulatory capture was further sanctioned by Yukon Government’s prioritization of mining’s economic outcomes over ecological ones. The resulting loss of what could have been – the highest level of ecological recovery and resulting lifeways that were possible if policy had been implemented – is difficult to characterize, yet as locally harmful as the toxicity of contaminants. To break out of this pattern, we recommend separating the promotion and regulation of mining within governments and establishing an authoritative role in mineral governance for those with a long-term investment in ecological recovery, such as Indigenous peoples and local communities.