Comparative Study of Methods for Caries Risk Evaluation: CAMBRA, the Cariogram, and Caries Risk Semaphore
Authors:
- Iris Català-BenaventICIris Català-Benavent
- José Enrique Iranzo-CortésJIJosé Enrique Iranzo-Cortés
- Teresa Almerich-TorresTeresa Almerich-Torres
- Cecilia Fabiana Márquez-ArricoCMCecilia Fabiana Márquez-Arrico
- José Manuel Almerich-SillaJAJosé Manuel Almerich-Silla
- José María Montiel-CompanyJMJosé María Montiel-Company
Open Access
- 30 July 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Clinical Medicine
- Vol. 14 (15) , 5378
Abstract
Background/Objectives: Caries risk assessment is essential for the management of dental caries. There are different assessment methods with the most commonly used being CAMBRA, the Cariogram, and Caries Risk Semaphore (CRS). The aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic agreement between the three different caries risk assessment methods mentioned above. Methods: This study was conducted in the Dental Clinic of the University of Valencia by Preventive and Community Dentistry II students on patients examined during clinical practices (n = 672). Patients were evaluated to determine their caries risk using the three methods named above. A descriptive analysis of the sample was performed, and diagnostic agreement was assessed using the Kappa coefficient. Results: According to CRS, 321 patients (48%) showed high risk, 96 patients (14%) moderate risk, and 255 (38%) low risk. The highest diagnostic agreement was found between CRS and CAMBRA, with an unweighted Kappa of 0.36. Regarding risk severity assessments, the highest Kappa was also observed between CRS and CAMBRA, with a Kappa of 0.46 for low risk, 0.14 for moderate risk, and 0.40 for high risk. Conclusions: There is an important heterogeneity in the obtained results. This highlights the need to further study different caries risk assessment methods and determine their predictive capacity to choose the one that yields the best outcome.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessment of predictive performance of caries risk assessment models based on a systematic review and meta-analysisJournal of Dentistry, 2021
- CariesCare practice guide: consensus on evidence into practiceBritish Dental Journal, 2019
- The validity of caries risk assessment in young adults with past caries experience using a screening Cariogram model without saliva testsInternational Dental Journal, 2018
- Risk assessment – can we achieve consensus?Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology, 2013
- Evidence on existing caries risk assessment systems: are they predictive of future caries?Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology, 2012
- Caries Risk Assessment in Practice for Age 6 Through AdultJournal of the California Dental Association, 2007
- Clinical Protocols for Caries Management by Risk AssessmentJournal of the California Dental Association, 2007
- Cariogram – a multifactorial risk assessment model for a multifactorial diseaseCommunity Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology, 2005
- Evaluation of a computer-based caries risk assessment program in an elderly group of individualsActa Odontologica Scandinavica, 2003
- Evaluation of a Computer Program for Caries Risk Assessment in SchoolchildrenCaries Research, 2002