Incongruence in Doping Related Attitudes, Beliefs and Opinions in the Context of Discordant Behavioural Data: In Which Measure Do We Trust?
Open Access
- 26 April 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 6 (4) , e18804
Abstract
Social psychology research on doping and outcome based evaluation of primary anti-doping prevention and intervention programmes have been dominated by self-reports. Having confidence in the validity and reliability of such data is vital. The sample of 82 athletes from 30 sports (52.4% female, mean age: 21.48±2.86 years) was split into quasi-experimental groups based on i) self-admitted previous experience with prohibited performance enhancing drugs (PED) and ii) the presence of at least one prohibited PED in hair covering up to 6 months prior to data collection. Participants responded to questionnaires assessing a range of social cognitive determinants of doping via self-reports; and completed a modified version of the Brief Implicit Association Test (BIAT) assessing implicit attitudes to doping relative to the acceptable nutritional supplements (NS). Social projection regarding NS was used as control. PEDs were detected in hair samples from 10 athletes (12% prevalence), none of whom admitted doping use. This group of ‘deniers’ was characterised by a dissociation between explicit (verbal declarations) and implicit (BIAT) responding, while convergence was observed in the ‘clean’ athlete group. This dissociation, if replicated, may act as a cognitive marker of the denier group, with promising applications of the combined explicit-implicit cognitive protocol as a proxy in lieu of biochemical detection methods in social science research. Overall, discrepancies in the relationship between declared doping-related opinion and implicit doping attitudes were observed between the groups, with control measures remaining unaffected. Questionnaire responses showed a pattern consistent with self-reported doping use. Following our preliminary work, this study provides further evidence that both self-reports on behaviour and social cognitive measures could be affected by some form of response bias. This can question the validity of self-reports, with reliability remaining unaffected. Triangulation of various assessment methods is recommended.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inside athletes' minds: Preliminary results from a pilot study on mental representation of doping and potential implications for anti-dopingSubstance Abuse Treatment, Prevention, and Policy, 2011
- Methodological considerations regarding response bias effect in substance use research: is correlation between the measured variables sufficient?Substance Abuse Treatment, Prevention, and Policy, 2011
- How good is fine-grained Timeline Follow-back data? Comparing 30-day TLFB and repeated 7-day TLFB alcohol consumption reports on the person and daily levelAddictive Behaviors, 2010
- Just Say “I Don't”: Lack of Concordance Between Teen Report and Biological Measures of Drug UsePediatrics, 2010
- Virtue or Pretense? Looking behind Self-Declared Innocence in DopingPLOS ONE, 2010
- The reliability and validity of drug users' self reports of amphetamine use among primarily heroin and cocaine usersAddictive Behaviors, 2010
- Measurement of self-reported HIV risk behaviors in injection drug users: Comparison of standard versus timeline follow-back administration proceduresJournal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 2010
- A Mediation Analysis of the ATHENA Intervention for Female Athletes: Prevention of Athletic-Enhancing Substance Use and Unhealthy Weight Loss BehaviorsJournal of Pediatric Psychology, 2009
- Comparison between self-report and hair analysis of illicit drug use in a community sample of middle-aged menAddictive Behaviors, 2008
- Discrepancies between self-report and objective measures for stimulant drug use in HIV: Cognitive, medication adherence and psychological correlatesAddictive Behaviors, 2007