Registered Report: A Replication Examining Occupational Experience and Performance on the Water-Level Task
Authors:
- Elizabeth R. TenneyETElizabeth R. Tenney
- Kylie RochfordKRKylie Rochford
- Amelia StillwellASAmelia Stillwell
- Coco Xinyue LiuCLCoco Xinyue Liu
- David TannenbaumDTDavid Tannenbaum
- Marie HenneckeMHMarie Hennecke
- Jeanine K. StefanucciJSJeanine K. Stefanucci
- B. Ariel BlairBBB. Ariel Blair
- Jesse GrahamJGJesse Graham
- Bryan L. BonnerBBBryan L. Bonner
- 9 February 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Psychological Science
- Vol. 37 (2) , 125-135
Abstract
This is a registered report to directly replicate the primary finding in Hecht and Proffitt (1995). Hecht and Proffitt found that those with occupational experience handling liquid in containers performed worse at solving a water-level problem than those in occupations that did not require handling liquids. Shortly after, Vasta et al. (1997) found the opposite: Experience was associated with superior performance on the task. The conflicting findings and the small sample sizes in each study leave the relationship between experience and water-level-task performance uncertain. We addressed these concerns with a high-powered direct replication of Hecht and Proffitt with adults in Germany ( N = 407). We failed to replicate Hecht and Proffitt’s results, finding that their study had less than 33% power to detect the small, nonsignificant difference that we observed between groups.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- The relation between prior knowledge and learning in regular and gifted classes: A multigroup latent growth curve analysis.Journal of Educational Psychology, 2024
- Deciding what to replicate: A decision model for replication study selection under resource and knowledge constraints.Psychological Methods, 2023
- Improving social and behavioral science by making replication mainstream: A response to commentariesBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 2018
- The paradox of human expertise: why experts get it wrong2011
- Why and how do creative thinking techniques work?: Trading off originality and appropriateness to make more creative advertisingJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2009
- Piaget’s water-level tasks: Performance across the lifespan with emphasis on the elderlyPersonality and Individual Differences, 2008
- Inflexibility of experts—Reality or myth? Quantifying the Einstellung effect in chess mastersCognitive Psychology, 2008
- Understanding the surface orientation of liquidsCognitive Psychology, 1991
- SEX‐TYPING OF THE WATER‐LEVEL TASK: THERE IS MORE THAN MEETS THE EYEInternational Journal of Psychology, 1990
- Comparative research methodology: Cross‐cultural studiesInternational Journal of Psychology, 1976