Medical Liability of the Physician in Training
- 1 May 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research
- Vol. 470 (5) , 1379-1385
Abstract
Tioned whether the proper standard governing resident physician conduct should be that of a reasonably competent generalist physician, that of a specialty physician, or whether the standard should be some subjective determination that addresses the resident level of training. Questions/purposes We examined legal cases in which the standard of care for a physician in training has been questioned. Additionally, we address how resident conduct can extend liability to supervising physicians and employer hospitals. Methods Westlaw™ and LexisNexis®, two major legal databases used by law professionals, were searched to identify existing case law and law review articles related to the standard of care that applies to physicians in training. Of 57 sources initially identified, 15 legal cases and 10 law review papers addressed the standard of care pertaining to physicians in training. These selected cases and papers form the basis of the present article. Results The standard by which the professional conduct of a physician in training is measured has varied; most recent legal cases have applied a specialty physician standard. Relevant court rulings have tried to strike a balance between patient interests versus the societal need to train physicians. Conclusions Physician representation, nature of conduct, and extent of supervision of that conduct are relevant factors used by courts to determine liability. However, the recent standards are those of the physician who directly supervises the professional conduct of a resident in a given situation....Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- When Are Residents Treated as Doctors Under the Law?AMA Journal of Ethics, 2009
- A Longitudinal Study of Emergency Medicine Residents' Malpractice Fear and Defensive MedicineAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2007
- The standard of care for residents and other medical school graduates in training.2006
- Professional Liability Issues in Graduate Medical EducationJAMA, 2004
- The second revolution in informed consent: Comparing physicians to each other1999
- Isolated mesenteric arteries from pregnant rats show enhanced flow‐mediated relaxation but normal myogenic tone.The Journal of Physiology, 1996
- Professional liability in postgraduate medical educationJournal of Legal Medicine, 1994
- Forty years of litigation involving residents and their trainingAcademic Medicine, 1991
- Informed consent to medical treatment: an analysis of recent legislation.1980