Rethinking the Reliability of Eyewitness Memory
Open Access
- 2 May 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perspectives on Psychological Science
- Vol. 13 (3) , 324-335
Abstract
Although certain pockets within the broad field of academic psychology have come to appreciate that eyewitness memory is more reliable than was once believed, the prevailing view, by far, is that eyewitness memory is unreliable—a blanket assessment that increasingly pervades the legal system. On the surface, this verdict seems unavoidable: Research convincingly shows that memory is malleable, and eyewitness misidentifications are known to have played a role in most of the DNA exonerations of the innocent. However, we argue here that, like DNA evidence and other kinds of scientifically validated forensic evidence, eyewitness memory is reliable if it is not contaminated and if proper testing procedures are used. This conclusion applies to eyewitness memory broadly conceived, whether the test involves recognition (from a police lineup) or recall (during a police interview). From this perspective, eyewitness memory has been wrongfully convicted of mistakes that are better construed as having been committed by other actors in the legal system, not by the eyewitnesses themselves. Eyewitnesses typically provide reliable evidence on an initial, uncontaminated memory test, and this is true even for most of the wrongful convictions that were later reversed by DNA evidence.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Department of Justice (DJF-15-1200-V-0010434)
- Economic and Social Research Council (ES/L012642/1)
- National Science Foundation (SES-1155248)
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- A field study of adult witness interviewing practices in a Canadian police organizationLegal and Criminological Psychology, 2011
- Estimating the impact of estimator variables on eyewitness identification: A fruitful marriage of practical problem solving and psychological theorizingApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2008
- Does the type of prompt affect the accuracy of information provided by alleged victims of abuse in forensic interviews?Applied Cognitive Psychology, 2007
- The Man Behind the Mask: Accuracy and Predictors of Eyewitness Offender Descriptions.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2004
- Selecting accurate statements from the cognitive interview using confidence ratings.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2002
- Watching the birdie watching you: eyewitness memory for actions using CCTV recordings of actual crimesApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2001
- The cognitive interview: A meta-analysisPsychology, Crime & Law, 1999
- Portraying perpetrators: The validity of offender descriptions by witnesses.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- The Possible Role of Source Misattributions in the Creation of False Beliefs Among PreschoolersInternational Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis, 1994
- Field test of the cognitive interview: Enhancing the recollection of actual victims and witnesses of crime.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1989