Abstract
This study explored the role of (dis)confirmation in family mental health conversations. One hundred sixteen parent–young adult child dyads from Black, Latinx, Asian, white, and multiethnic-racial families in the United States participated in a Zoom conversation about mental health. These conversations were analyzed using a phronetic iterative approach. The findings expand upon the concepts of acceptance and challenge to introduce further nuance to confirmation theory. Specifically, the authors proposed the constructs of strict and gentle challenge and considered the role of explicit, absent, and implicit acceptance in these conversations. Both individually and together, these constructs appeared to correspond with varying degrees of (dis)confirmation. The authors considered factors that corresponded with the appearance of (dis)confirmation, including openness as a precursor for confirmation, (dis)confirmation reinforcing or redefining normative beliefs, and the role of confirmation gaps. The authors explored the implications of these findings on confirmation theory and family mental health communication research.

This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit: