Assessing Ride Motion Discomfort Measurement Formulas
Open Access
Abstract
This article is about a framework for determining the degree of realism of any given passenger ride motion discomfort measurement formula. After providing some context and reviewing evidence of deficiency in currently popular ride motion discomfort measurement formulas, the article outlines the research program that needs to be carried out in order to establish such a framework. The research begins with gathering recordings of uncomfortable ride motion episodes encountered in a chosen type of passenger transport service. It then has test subjects compare the episodes via a ride motion simulator and adjust their amplitudes pair wise until they cause equal discomfort. It explains how to take the pair wise amplitude adjustments and determine amplitude adjustments that bring all of the motion episode recordings to a common level of discomfort so that they form a normalized set. Then, the lower the scatter of the scores assigned by any given discomfort measurement formula to the members of that set, the more realistic that formula will be for the chosen service.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Methods of Passenger Ride Comfort Evaluation—Tests for Metro CarsSensors, 2023
- Evaluation of Ride Comfort in a Railway Passenger Car Depending on a Change of Suspension ParametersSensors, 2021
- Study on the Evaluation Methods of the Vertical Ride Comfort of Railway Vehicle—Mean Comfort Method and Sperling’s MethodApplied Sciences, 2021
- Correlation between Ride Comfort Index and Sperling's Index for Evaluation Ride Comfort in Railway VehiclesApplied Mechanics and Materials, 2018
- Influences of Carbody Vertical Flexibility on Ride Comfort of Railway VehiclesArchive of Mechanical Engineering, 2017
- Mechatronic Rail Vehicle Design Based on the Passenger ComfortJournal of Engineering Science and Technology Review, 2016
- Comparison between ISO 2631–1 Comfort Prediction Equations and Self-Reported Comfort Values during Occupational Exposure to Whole-Body Vehicular VibrationJournal of Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Control, 2012
- Subjective ratings of whole-body vibration for single- and multi-axis motionThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2011
- Evaluation of subjective responses to whole-body vibration exposure: Effect of frequency contentInternational Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 2008
- Evaluation of Whole-Body Vibration by the Category Judgment MethodIndustrial Health, 2005