Anarchy, Scarcity, Nature: Rousseau’s Stag Hunt and the Arctic Walrus Hunt Compared
Open Access
- 8 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Political Science Review
- Vol. 118 (3) , 1145-1157
Abstract
Under conditions of anarchy, the predominant assumption is that scarcity leads to conflict. I contrast traditional Inuit walrus hunt practices to Rousseau’s stag hunt to demonstrate how mainstream international relations has it wrong on three counts: (1) radical scarcity need not lead to conflict-prone outcomes, (2) the historical eighteenth-century context of the stag hunt does not prove a predisposition against cooperation, and (3) the conditions of anarchy are irreducible to cultural institutions or to material constraints alone. I leverage Latour’s “symmetrical anthropology” to demonstrate that ideas and things have an equal potential to structure the culture of anarchical relations and to build on the literature which has established that comparative cultural data can be used to theorize anarchy. Rethinking the logic of anarchy is especially important in the age of the Anthropocene, given the prospects for radical ecological change in the near future.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Elements of the Structures of International SystemsInternational Organization, 2012
- Anthropology and anarchy: Romance, horror or science fiction?Critique of Anthropology, 2012
- Hobbes, Savagery, and International AnarchyAmerican Political Science Review, 2011
- Evolution and Anarchism in International Relations: The Challenge of Kropotkin’s Biological OntologyMillennium: Journal of International Studies, 2010
- Food insecurity among Inuit preschoolers: Nunavut Inuit Child Health Survey, 2007-2008Canadian Medical Association Journal, 2010
- Pacific walruses, indigenous hunters, and climate change: Bridging scientific and indigenous knowledgeDeep Sea Research Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography, 2007
- Why a World State is InevitableEuropean Journal of International Relations, 2003
- A security regime among democracies: cooperation among Iroquois nationsInternational Organization, 1994
- Anarchy is what states make of it: the social construction of power politicsInternational Organization, 1992
- The agent-structure problem in international relations theoryInternational Organization, 1987