Development and application of an evidence-based directed acyclic graph to evaluate the associations between metal mixtures and cardiometabolic outcomes
Preprint
Abstract
Background Exposure to individual metals (and metalloids; hereafter ‘metals’) is associated with adverse cardiometabolic outcomes. Specifying analytic models to assess relationships among metal mixtures and cardiometabolic outcomes requires evidence-based models of the (assumed) causal structures; however, such models have not been previously published. Methods We conducted a systematic literature review to develop an evidence-based directed acyclic graph (DAG) identifying relationships among metals, cardiometabolic health indicators, and potential confounders. To evaluate the consistency of the DAG with data from 1797 participants in the San Luis Valley Diabetes Study (SLVDS; mean age=54 years, 53% women, 48% Hispanic), we tested conditional independence statements suggested by the DAG and by 100 DAGs with the same structure but randomly permuted nodes using linear (continuous outcomes), logistic (dichotomous outcomes), or Bayesian kernel machine regression (BKMR; statements with metal coexposures) models. Based on minimally sufficient adjustment sets identified by the DAG, we specified BKMR models assessing associations between urinary metal mixtures and cardiometabolic outcomes in the SLVDS population. Results Twenty-nine articles met the inclusion criteria for the systematic review. From these articles, we developed an evidence-based DAG with 382 testable conditional independence statements (71% supported by SLVDS data). Only 3% of the DAGs with randomly permuted nodes indicated more agreement with the data than our evidence-based DAG. Applying the evidence-based DAG in a pilot analysis, we did not observe evidence for an association among metal mixtures and cardiometabolic outcomes. Conclusions We developed, tested, and applied an evidence-based approach to analyze associations between metal mixtures and cardiometabolic health. What this study adds We conducted a systematic literature review to develop an evidence-based directed acyclic graph (DAG) of the presumed causal relationship between exposure to metal mixtures and cardiometabolic outcomes. Using real data, we evaluated the testable conditional independence statements. The evidence-based DAG outperformed 97% of DAGs with randomly permuted nodes. We applied the evidence-based DAG to select covariates for a pilot analysis. Environmental Epidemiology readers can (1) plan future research based on our systematic literature review, (2) use our process to evaluate other evidence-based DAGs, and (3) apply the evidence-based covariates sets to further explore relationships between metal mixtures and cardiometabolic health.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Epidemiologic Methods, 12 (s1), 20220133.
This publication has 62 references indexed in Scilit:
- High Urinary Tungsten Concentration Is Associated with Stroke in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 1999–2010PLOS ONE, 2013
- Predicting Later-Life Outcomes of Early-Life ExposuresEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2012
- Arsenic Exposure and Hypertension: A Systematic ReviewEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2012
- Urinary heavy metals and associated medical conditions in the US adult populationInternational Journal of Environmental Health Research, 2011
- Arsenic: toxicity, oxidative stress and human diseaseJournal of Applied Toxicology, 2011
- Creatinine determination according to Jaffe--what does it stand for?Clinical Kidney Journal, 2011
- Drinking-Water Arsenic Exposure Modulates Gene Expression in Human Lymphocytes from a U.S. PopulationEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2008
- Trace Metals in Urine of United States Residents: Reference Range ConcentrationsEnvironmental Research, 1998
- Causal diagrams for empirical researchBiometrika, 1995
- The role of dietary fiber in the etiology of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitusAnnals of Epidemiology, 1993