Quantifying Temporal Instability in Ecological Assemblages Using Modern Portfolio Theory

Authors:
  • CCChristian Che-Castaldo
    Christian Che-Castaldo
  • DMDavid Matteson
    David Matteson

Abstract
Temporal instability is an important component of biodiversity loss but is not well captured by frameworks based on static biodiversity metrics. We apply metrics from modern portfolio theory to quantify changes in assemblage stability over time and identify individual species’ contributions to instability. Using temporal species abundance data from the Breeding Bird Survey, we estimate volatility and co-movement within bird assemblages defined by breeding biomes. Assemblage volatility closely tracked the coefficient of variation in total abundance, a widely used measure of temporal variability, but detected changes in variability more rapidly and allowed exact decomposition into species-level contributions. Consistent with ecological theory, assemblage instability was driven primarily by variation in the abundance of dominant species. Species with faster life histories also contributed disproportionately to instability, even after accounting for their abundance and abundance volatility. In the most diverse assemblage, however, instability was driven primarily by synchrony among species rather than volatility of dominant species. These portfolio-based metrics provide a dynamic and decomposable measure of ecological stability that can identify the species and co-movement patterns driving changes in biodiversity over time.