Race and Public Deliberation
Authors:
- Tali MendelbergTMTali Mendelberg
- John OleskeJOJohn Oleske
- 1 April 2000
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Political Communication
- Vol. 17 (2) , 169-191
Abstract
Although deliberation has a central place in democratic theory, scholars know little about how it actually works. Most deliberative theorists emphasize the many good consequences of deliberation. By contrast, Mansbridge suggests that deliberation in certain circumstances may exacerbate conflict. Scholarship on racial politics suggests that each hypothesis is complicated by implicitly racial language. Using a quasi-experiment, we contrast the rhetoric in two town meetings about school desegregation: a segregated meeting with homogeneous interests, in which segregated Whites unanimously argued against desegregation, and an integrated meeting with heterogeneous interests, in which segregated Whites argued against integrated Whites, Hispanics, and African Americans. We find that (a) deliberation at the segregated meeting maintained consensus among segregated Whites; (b) these citizens used coded rhetoric that appeared universal, well-reasoned, and focused on the common good, but in fact advanced their group interest; (c) deliberation at the integrated meeting maintained the conflict between segregated Whites and others; and (d) there, rhetoric that seemed universal to segregated Whites was decoded by the integrated audience as racist and group interested. We highlight the problem posed by the contested meaning of language and suggest ways to make deliberation more effective.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Increasing Political Sophistication Through Public DeliberationPolitical Communication, 1999
- Unity and Diversity in American Political Culture: An Exploratory Study of the National Conversation on American Pluralism and IdentityPolitical Psychology, 1998
- Defended Neighborhoods, Integration, and Racially Motivated CrimeAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1998
- Public Perceptions of Race and Crime: The Role of Racial StereotypesAmerican Journal of Political Science, 1997
- Nonrandom Measurement Error and Race of Interviewer Effects Among African AmericansPublic Opinion Quarterly, 1997
- Beyond Racial Threat: Failure of an Old Hypothesis in the New SouthThe Journal of Politics, 1996
- Beyond Friendship: Aristotle on Conflict, Deliberation, and AttentionThe Journal of Politics, 1996
- Cracks in American Apartheid: The Political Impact of Prejudice among Desegregated WhitesThe Journal of Politics, 1995
- On Hearing and Interpreting Political Messages: A Cautionary Tale of Citizen Cue-TakingThe Journal of Politics, 1994
- Democratic Theory and Self-TransformationAmerican Political Science Review, 1992