Combining verbal forecasts: The role of directionality and the reinforcement effect
Open Access
- 29 August 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 36 (2)
Abstract
Recent research has shown that when people combine verbal probabilistic forecasts from two sources, they are not simply averaged but can reinforce each other; so when two advisors both said an event was “rather likely,” some listeners concluded that the event was “quite likely”. Conversely, when both said the event was “rather unlikely,” people concluded that it was “quite unlikely.” The present studies demonstrate that the direction of this effect is not evoked by high versus low probabilities, but by the directionality of verbal probability expressions. Some phrases are affirmative, directed towards occurrences (“there is a chance”), whereas others are negations, pointing to the possibility that the event might not occur (“it is not certain”). Two positive phrases are perceived to reinforce each other, even when they convey low probabilities, resulting in a higher combined probability estimate, whereas two negative phrases do the opposite, regardless of the probabilities they convey. We show that this effect occurs both for equal and unequal verbal phrases, regardless of the probability equivalents of the expressions. We also found a positive, but weaker, reinforcement effect of numerical probabilities.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Is guilt ‘likely’ or ‘not certain’?Acta Psychologica, 2010
- Motivated reasoning and verbal vs. numerical probability assessment: Evidence from an accounting contextOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2009
- The Effect of Numerical Statements of Risk on Trust and Comfort with Hypothetical Physician Risk CommunicationMedical Decision Making, 2004
- What a speaker’s choice of frame reveals: Reference points, frame selection, and framing effectsPsychonomic Bulletin & Review, 2003
- Verbal probabilities: a question of frame?Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2002
- Ambiguous probabilities: when doesp=0.3 reflect a possibility, and when does it express a doubt?Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2000
- The Directionality of Verbal Probability Expressions: Effects on Decisions, Predictions, and Probabilistic ReasoningOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1999
- Yes, but it is uncertain: Direction and communicative intention of verbal probabilistic termsActa Psychologica, 1995
- The language of uncertaintyActa Psychologica, 1988
- Extensional versus intuitive reasoning: The conjunction fallacy in probability judgment.Psychological Review, 1983