Flutter and Directional Stability of Aircraft with Wing-Tip Fins: Conflicts and Compromises
Authors:
- 1 March 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) in Journal of Aircraft
- Vol. 50 (2) , 615-625
Abstract
An alternative to vertical tails, wing-tip fins, a type of winglet, provide yaw stability and control and some operational and maintenance advantages. Winglets reduce wing-induced drag but may reduce flutter speed, requiring wing stiffening and a structural weight penalty. Whereas the number of successful aircraft with winglets suggests that many flutter studies have been done, few of these studies appear in the archival literature. This paper investigates the effect of tip-fin surface geometry on flutter as well as on directional stability. The study includes the effects of tip-fin cant angle with respect to the primary surface and fin size with respect to the wing itself. Two idealized models, a simple four degree-of-freedom Rayleigh–Ritz model and a high-fidelity finite element model, illustrate special features of tip-fin aeroelasticity. Results indicate that the interaction between tip fins and the wing flexibility usually leads to reduced flutter speeds but can also create phenomena such as mode switching that actually increases flutter speed if the fin is large enough. Classical wing-surface lift ineffectiveness due to aeroelastic interaction also reduces directional stability.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Tail Design2012
- Vibration and Flutter Characteristics of a Folding WingJournal of Aircraft, 2009
- Numerical and Experimental Analysis of a Generic Fan-in-Wing ConfigurationJournal of Aircraft, 2009
- Experimental Investigation of Bistable Winglets to Enhance Aircraft Wing Lift Takeoff CapabilityJournal of Aircraft, 2009
- Multidisciplinary Design Exploration for a WingletJournal of Aircraft, 2008
- Improving Hang-Glider Maneuverability Using Multiple Winglets: A Numerical and Experimental InvestigationJournal of Aircraft, 2008
- Aircraft Control via Variable Cant-Angle WingletsJournal of Aircraft, 2008
- Winglet effects on the flutter of a twin-engine transport-type wingJournal of Aircraft, 1985
- Transonic flutter model study of a supercritical wing and wingletJournal of Aircraft, 1983
- Effect of Winglets on Performance and Handling Qualities of General Aviation AircraftJournal of Aircraft, 1981