Abstract
The report by Winawer et al. (June 15 issue)1 on the sensitivity of double-contrast barium enema for detecting colonic adenomas requires comment. The overall sensitivity of double-contrast barium enema was 39 percent, with a sensitivity of 48 percent for detecting adenomas larger than 1 cm. Only 23 adenomas larger than 1 cm were detected among the seven participating institutions, and most were between 11 and 15 mm (Stewart E: personal communication). The measurement method used in the study has been shown to overestimate significantly the true size. In one review, half the lesions endoscopically classified as more than 1 cm were proved to be smaller.2 In the study by Winawer et al., the fact that the sensitivity for adenomas that were 6 to 10 mm was similar to the sensitivity for those classified as larger supports the belief that most of the “larger polyps” belonged in the group of smaller polyps. A table listing the size, histologic features, and location of adenomas larger than 1 cm and also noting those detected by double-contrast barium enema was not provided. With the small sample and likelihood of measurement error, conclusions about the sensitivity of double-contrast barium enema for detecting polyps larger than 1 cm are premature.

This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit: