Comparison of Colonoscopy and Double-Contrast Barium Enema
Author:
- T FibusTFT Fibus
- 7 December 2000
- journal article
- letter
- Published by Massachusetts Medical Society in New England Journal of Medicine
- Vol. 343 (23) , 1728-1730
Abstract
The report by Winawer et al. (June 15 issue)1 on the sensitivity of double-contrast barium enema for detecting colonic adenomas requires comment. The overall sensitivity of double-contrast barium enema was 39 percent, with a sensitivity of 48 percent for detecting adenomas larger than 1 cm. Only 23 adenomas larger than 1 cm were detected among the seven participating institutions, and most were between 11 and 15 mm (Stewart E: personal communication). The measurement method used in the study has been shown to overestimate significantly the true size. In one review, half the lesions endoscopically classified as more than 1 cm were proved to be smaller.2 In the study by Winawer et al., the fact that the sensitivity for adenomas that were 6 to 10 mm was similar to the sensitivity for those classified as larger supports the belief that most of the “larger polyps” belonged in the group of smaller polyps. A table listing the size, histologic features, and location of adenomas larger than 1 cm and also noting those detected by double-contrast barium enema was not provided. With the small sample and likelihood of measurement error, conclusions about the sensitivity of double-contrast barium enema for detecting polyps larger than 1 cm are premature.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Factors That Predict Incomplete Colonoscopy: Thinner Is Not Always BetterAmerican Journal of Gastroenterology, 2000
- A Comparison of Colonoscopy and Double-Contrast Barium Enema for Surveillance after PolypectomyNew England Journal of Medicine, 2000
- Effect of initial polypectomy versus surveillance polypectomy on colorectal cancer incidence reduction: Micro-simulation modeling of national polyp study dataGastroenterology, 2000
- A Comparison of Virtual and Conventional Colonoscopy for the Detection of Colorectal PolypsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1999
- The pathologic measurement of polyp size is preferable to the endoscopic estimateGastrointestinal Endoscopy, 1997
- Colorectal cancer screening: Clinical guidelines and rationaleGastroenterology, 1997
- Colonoscopic miss rates of adenomas determined by back-to-back colonoscopiesGastroenterology, 1997
- Double-contrast Barium Enema versus Colonoscopy in the Diagnosis of Neoplastic Disorders: Aspects of Decision-making in General PracticeFamily Practice, 1993
- ColonoscopyJournal of Clinical Gastroenterology, 1992
- Prospective Study of the Frequency and Size Distribution of Polyps Missed by ColonoscopyJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 1990