Ethical Considerations in Umbilical Cord Blood Banking
Authors:
- Nathan S. FoxNFNathan S. Fox
- Frank A. ChervenakFCFrank A. Chervenak
- Laurence B. McCulloughLMLaurence B. McCullough
- 1 January 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Obstetrics & Gynecology
- Vol. 111 (1) , 178-182
Abstract
Pregnant patients have the option at delivery of having their cord blood collected and stored for future use. At many hospitals, they have the option of donating their cord blood to the public banking system for future use by anyone who is an appropriate match (public banking). Patients also have the option of having their cord blood stored for a fee with a commercial/private company for future use within their family (private banking). Currently, private banking is not recommended by major obstetric and pediatric professional organizations. We applied current evidence of the risks and benefits of private and public cord blood banking and accepted ethical principles to answer the following two related questions: 1) Do obstetricians have an ethical obligation to comply with a request for private banking? and 2) Do obstetricians have an ethical obligation to routinely offer private banking to women who do not request it? The only situation where there is a known benefit to private banking is when public banking is not available and the patient currently has an affected family member who may benefit from cord blood therapy. We conclude that when presented with a request for private banking, obstetricians have an ethical obligation to explain the lack of proven benefit of this procedure. If the patient still requests private banking, it would be appropriate to comply, because there is minimal or no risk to the procedure. However, obstetricians are not ethically obligated to offer private banking, even when public banking is not available, except in the limited circumstance when the patient currently has an affected family member who may benefit from cord blood therapy.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cord Blood Banking for Potential Future TransplantationPediatrics, 2007
- NHS maternity units should not encourage commercial banking of umbilical cord bloodBMJ, 2006
- RETIRED: Umbilical Cord Blood Banking: Implications for Perinatal Care ProvidersJournal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada, 2005
- Can Routine Commercial Cord Blood Banking Be Scientifically and Ethically Justified?PLOS Medicine, 2005
- Transplants of Umbilical-Cord Blood or Bone Marrow from Unrelated Donors in Adults with Acute LeukemiaNew England Journal of Medicine, 2004
- Outcomes after Transplantation of Cord Blood or Bone Marrow from Unrelated Donors in Adults with LeukemiaNew England Journal of Medicine, 2004
- Outcomes among 562 Recipients of Placental-Blood Transplants from Unrelated DonorsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1998
- Outcome of Cord-Blood Transplantation from Related and Unrelated DonorsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1997
- Placental Blood as a Source of Hematopoietic Stem Cells for Transplantation into Unrelated RecipientsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1996
- Hematopoietic Reconstitution in a Patient with Fanconi's Anemia by Means of Umbilical-Cord Blood from an HLA-Identical SiblingNew England Journal of Medicine, 1989