Examining Transparency in Kidney Transplant Recipient Selection Criteria: Nationwide Cross-Sectional Study (Preprint)
Authors:
- Belen RiveraBRBelen Rivera
- Stalin CanizaresSCStalin Canizares
- Gabriel Cojuc-KonigsbergGCGabriel Cojuc-Konigsberg
- Olena HolubOHOlena Holub
- Alex NakonechnyiANAlex Nakonechnyi
- Ritah R ChumdermpadetsukRCRitah R Chumdermpadetsuk
- Keren LadinKLKeren Ladin
- Devin E EckhoffDEDevin E Eckhoff
- Rebecca AllenRARebecca Allen
- Aditya PawarAPAditya Pawar
Preprint
- 17 March 2025
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
BACKGROUND Choosing a transplant program impacts a patient’s likelihood of receiving a kidney transplant. Most patients are unaware of the factors influencing their candidacy. As patients increasingly rely on online resources for health care decisions, this study quantifies the available online patient-level information on kidney transplant recipient (KTR) selection criteria across US kidney transplant centers. OBJECTIVE We aimed to use natural language processing and a large language model to quantify the available online patient-level information regarding the guideline-recommended KTR selection criteria reported by US transplant centers. METHODS A cross-sectional study using natural language processing and a large language model was conducted to review the websites of US kidney transplant centers from June to August 2024. Links were explored up to 3 levels deep, and information on 31 guideline-recommended KTR selection criteria was collected from each transplant center. RESULTS A total of 255 US kidney transplant centers were analyzed, comprising 10,508 web pages and 9,113,753 words. Among the kidney transplant guideline–recommended KTR selection criteria, only 2.6% (206/7905) of the information was present on the transplant center web pages. Socioeconomic and behavioral criteria were mentioned more than those related to the patient’s medical conditions and comorbidities. Of the 31 criteria, finances and health insurance was the most frequently mentioned, appearing in 25.5% (65/255) of the transplant centers. Other socioeconomic and behavioral criteria, such as family and social support systems, adherence, and psychosocial assessment, were addressed in less than 4% (9/255) of the transplant centers. No information was found on any web page for 45.2% (14/31) of the KTR selection criteria. Geographically, disparities in reporting were observed, with the South Atlantic division showing the highest number of distinct criteria, while New England had the fewest. CONCLUSIONS Most transplant center websites do not disclose patient-level KTR selection criteria online. The lack of transparency in the evaluation and listing process for kidney transplantation may limit patients in choosing their most suitable transplant center and successfully receiving a kidney transplant.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: JMIR AI, 4, e74066.
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Racial Disparities in Living Donor Kidney Transplantation—How Can We Bridge the Gap?JAMA Network Open, 2023
- Stakeholders’ perspectives on transplant metrics: the 2022 Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients’ consensus conferenceAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2023
- A Population Health Approach to Transplant Access: Challenging the Status QuoAmerican Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2022
- Improving Access to Kidney Transplantation: Perspectives From Dialysis and Transplant Staff in the Southeastern United StatesKidney Medicine, 2021
- KDOQI US Commentary on the 2020 KDIGO Clinical Practice Guideline on the Evaluation and Management of Candidates for Kidney TransplantationAmerican Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2021
- Attitude and potential benefits of modern information and communication technology use and telemedicine in cross-sectoral solid organ transplant careScientific Reports, 2021
- The Role of the General Nephrologist in Evaluating Patients for Kidney Transplantation: Core Curriculum 2020American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2020
- Natural language processing of electronic health records is superior to billing codes to identify symptom burden in hemodialysis patientsKidney International, 2020
- Barriers facing patients referred for kidney transplant cause loss to follow-upKidney International, 2012
- Selection Criteria and Total Cost of Ownership2005