Science, Equity, and the War against Carbon
Author:
- 1 January 2003
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Science, Technology, & Human Values
- Vol. 28 (1) , 69-92
Abstract
The scientific evidence is reviewed for claims that a global transition to “green” fuels and technologies by global treaty obligations is needed. The likely equity implications of these efforts are discussed, and it is argued that this evidence remains shaky. Measures based on this contested knowledge cannot be defended on grounds of either environmental effectiveness or equity. Rather, they rely on commercial expectations and promises of secondary (no regret or win-win) benefits usually requiring state intervention. Poorer groups and nations are unlikely to benefit from proposals to redirect energy policies to “combat global warming.” The advocated decarbonization of global energy supplies is more likely to increase political instability than prevent climatic change. To support this argument, three areas of knowledge are consulted: controversies about the causation and likely impacts of global warming, advocated technical and fiscal solutions, and the interests of technical, commercial, and political elites.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- President's Bush Letter to Three Senators Explaining His Rejection of the Kyoto Protocol: The White HouseEnergy & Environment, 2001
- Shaping the Nuclear FutureEnergy & Environment, 2000
- Differentiation since Kyoto: An Exploration of Australian Climate Policy in Comparison to Europe/UKEnergy & Environment, 2000
- The Changing Role of the European Union in International Environmental Politics: Institution Building and the Politics of Climate ChangeEnvironment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 1999
- Climate Change and the World Bank: Opportunity for Global Governance?Energy & Environment, 1999
- The Carbon Dioxide Thermometer and the Cause of Global WarmingEnergy & Environment, 1999
- A winning coalition of advocacy: climate research, bureaucracy and ‘alternative’ fuelsEnergy Policy, 1997
- Beyond Epistemology: Relativism and Engagement in the Politics of ScienceSocial Studies of Science, 1996
- Britain and the International Panel on climate change: The impacts of scientific advice on global warming part 1: Integrated policy analysis and the global dimensionEnvironmental Politics, 1995
- Global climate protection policy: the limits of scientific advice☆Part 1Global Environmental Change, 1994