An analysis of scoring via analytic rubric and general impression in peer assessment
Open Access
- 31 October 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Turkish Journal of Education in Turkish Journal of Education
- Vol. 8 (4) , 258-275
Abstract
The aim of this research was to analyze and compare analytic rubric and general impression scoring in peer assessment. A total of 66 university students participated in the study and six of them were chosen as peer raters on a voluntary basis. In the research, students were supposed to prepare a sample study within the scope of scientific research methods course and were also expected to present their studies in class. While the students were giving a presentation, their course instructor and peer raters conducted scoring, firstly by using the analytic rubric and subsequently by using general impressions. Collected data were analyzed using the Rasch model. Consequently, it was found that students were distinguished from one another at a highly reliable rate using both scoring methods. Additionally, it was discovered that the differences between students’ ability levels were better revealed when analytic rubric was used. It was ascertained that there was a high level positive correlation between the ability estimations obtained from the scores performed by the peers and the instructor, regardless of the scoring method used. Finally, it was determined that ability estimations, corresponding peer raters’ analytic rubric and general impression scoring, held a positive and highly strong relation.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Comparative Study on Self, Peer and Teacher Evaluation to Evaluate Clinical Skills of Nursing StudentsProcedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2012
- Rasch calibration of physical activity self-efficacy and social support scale for persons with intellectual disabilitiesResearch in Developmental Disabilities, 2010
- Peer AssessmentTheory Into Practice, 2009
- Self-, peer-, and teacher-assessments in Japanese university EFL writing classroomsLanguage Testing, 2009
- Relationships Among Instructor, Peer, and Self-Evaluations of Undergraduate Music Education Majors' Micro-Teaching ExperiencesJournal of Research in Music Education, 2008
- Peer feedback: the learning element of peer assessmentTeaching in Higher Education, 2006
- Designing student peer assessment in higher education: analysis of written and oral peer feedbackTeaching in Higher Education, 2006
- Student Peer Assessment in Higher Education: A Meta-Analysis Comparing Peer and Teacher MarksReview of Educational Research, 2000
- The Development of Critical Thinking Skills in Undergraduate Supervisory Management Units: efficacy of student peer assessmentAssessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 1999
- Peer Assessment Between Students in Colleges and UniversitiesReview of Educational Research, 1998