A RESPONSE TO DASGUPTA
Authors:
- 1 July 2007
- journal article
- essay
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Economics and Philosophy
- Vol. 23 (3) , 359-364
Abstract
The present note will be concerned only with Sir Partha Dasgupta's recent article in this journal (Dasgupta 2005). What is more, it will concentrate on those parts of the article which contain a serious misreading of Hilary Putnam's position on the entanglement of facts, theories and values. These philosophical matters can perhaps be clarified for economist readers (they should require no clarification for philosophers) by considering, to begin with, Dasgupta's interpretation of the Bergson–Samuelson position. What (Bergson) Burk (1938) and Samuelson (1947) were doing, according to Dasgupta, was to establish ‘the ethical foundations of the subject. . .over five decades ago’ (Dasgupta 2005: 221–2).2 Thus a major theme of the article is heard at once: economics is supposedly based on sound ethical foundations, and these can be traced (it is supposed) to specific work written long ago, and hence needing no augmentation. These ethical foundations, it is claimed, ‘are now regarded to be a settled matter’ (2005: 222).Keywords
This publication has 3 references indexed in Scilit:
- WHAT DO ECONOMISTS ANALYZE AND WHY: VALUES OR FACTS?Economics and Philosophy, 2005
- Mind, Language and Reality1975
- A Reformulation of Certain Aspects of Welfare EconomicsThe Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1938