Metal-Dependent Thermodynamics of Histidine-Mediated Protein Immobilization Revealed by Quantum Chemical Calculations

Authors:

Abstract
Metal-affinity interactions with proteins are widely used in site-directed enzyme immobilization, yet the thermodynamic factors governing metal-dependent binding remain poorly understood. Here, we combine quantum-mechanical calculations with experimental binding data to analyze imidazole coordination to Ni2+, Co2+, Zn2+ and Fe3+ chelated by IDA-and NTA-functionalized supports. Our quantum calculations reveal that Ni2+, and Co2+ show progressively more favorable coordination-shell formation and immobilization free energies as the number of coordinated imidazoles increases, with Ni2+ consistently more favorable than Co2+. On the other hand, Zn2+ exhibits a distinct preference for two-imidazole coordination, whereas Fe3+ is strongly modulated by hydrolysis, which substantially reduces its effective immobilization strength under neutral-pH conditions. These trends are qualitatively consistent with the experimental affinity order determined in the present work: Ni2+ > Zn2+ > Co2+ > Fe3+. To further connect theory and experiment, we define an apparent binding free energy based on mixed two-and three-imidazole coordination states that qualitatively reproduces the experimentally observed relative affinities. Moreover, QTAIM energy decomposition analysis further shows that the Fe-Imidazole interaction is intrinsically the strongest metal-imidazole interaction, although Fe3+ exhibits the lowest apparent affinity because of competition with hydrolytic species. This behavior fully explains the elution experiments, in which Fe3+-based systems exhibit stronger post-binding retention than the corresponding divalent metal complexes. Overall, the results show that metal-dependent enzyme immobilization can be rationalized by the combined effects of coordination preference, chelator environment, first-shell thermodynamics, and hydrolytic speciation, thereby providing a thermodynamic basis for designing improved metal-affinity supports.