COMPARISON OF RATING SCALES: SENSITIVITY, REPLICATES AND RELATIVE MEASUREMENT
Authors:
- 1 June 1986
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 1 (2) , 155-174
Abstract
The relative sensitivities of four scaling methods were assessed in central location tests with untrained judges. The scales included category scales, line scales, magnitude estimation, and a hybrid of the line and category scales. Approximate parity was observed among category scales, line scales and the hybrid scale in their ability to differentiate small physical differences. Magnitude estimation was used as efficiently as the other methods by a college population, but less efficiently by a heterogeneous sample of consumers. Judges used the scales with greater accuracy as they became familiar with the range of products to be judged. In spite of relatively small physical differences, subjects used wide ranges of the scales, supporting the view that rating scales are relative, not absolute, measuring instruments.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- THE DISRIMINATIVE EFFICIENCY OF COMMON SCALING METHODSJournal of Sensory Studies, 1986
- EVALUATION OF THREE SCALING METHODS FOR HEDONICSJournal of Sensory Studies, 1986
- Descriptive Sensory Assessment of Beef Steaks by Category Scaling, Line Scaling and Magnitude EstimationJournal of Food Science, 1985
- Measurement of Taste Intensity and Degree of Liking of Beverages by Graphic Scales and Magnitude EstimationJournal of Food Science, 1983
- A JND-scale/category-scale convergence in tastePerception & Psychophysics, 1983
- Problems with So-Called “Direct” Scaling1982
- RATIO SCALES AND CATEGORY SCALES OF ODOUR INTENSITYChemical Senses, 1975
- The surprising simplicity of sensory metrics.American Psychologist, 1962
- Improvement in perceptual judgments as a function of controlled practice or training.Psychological Bulletin, 1953
- ORGANOLEPTIC TESTS PERTAINING TO APPLES AND PEARS 1, 2Journal of Food Science, 1946