Comparison of virtual population analysis and statistical kill-at-age analysis for a recreational, kill-dominated fishery
Authors:
- Paul RadomskiPRPaul Radomski
- James R BenceJBJames R Bence
- Terrance J Quinn IiTITerrance J Quinn Ii
Open Access
- 1 February 2005
- journal article
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 62 (2) , 436-452
Abstract
We used simulations to compare the distributions of estimation errors for virtual population analysis using forward calculation (FVPA) and three variants of statistical kill-at-age analysis (KAA). The KAA variants assumed constant, time-blocked, and nonadditive selectivity. Simulations were based on a recreational walleye (Sander vitreus) fishery in Lake Mille Lacs, Minnesota. The focus of our experiments was on how model mis-specification (incorrect assumptions about selectivity for KAA or that kill had no error for FVPA) interacted with the magnitude of measurement errors and fishing mortality. We found that KAA models outperformed FVPA when they assumed the correct selectivity pattern, even when kill was measured without error. Of particular concern was a strong tendency by FVPA to overestimate stock size when kill was measured with substantial error. When KAA was based on an incorrect assumption regarding fishery selectivity and kill was measured with little error, wide distributions of errors and substantial biases sometimes resulted. KAA models that allowed fishery selectivity to change over time performed about as well as a constant-selectivity KAA model when selectivity was constant, and they performed much better when selectivity changed over time. Careful consideration of alternative fishery selectivity models should be a fundamental part of any age-structured assessment.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Initial Attempts to Actively Manage Recreational Fishery Harvest in MinnesotaNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2003
- A Statistical Model for Stock Assessment of Southern Bluefin Tuna with Temporal Changes in SelectivityAfrican Journal of Marine Science, 2003
- Estimating and testing non-additivity in fishing mortality: implications for detecting a fisheries collapseCanadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2002
- Using perceptions of data accuracy and empirical weighting of information: assessment of a recreational fish populationCanadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2000
- The retrospective problem in sequential population analysis: An investigation using cod fishery and simulated dataICES Journal of Marine Science, 1999
- Statistical analysis of catch-at-age data with correlated errorsCanadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 1995
- Comparative performance of ADAPT and Laurec-Shepherd methods for estimating fish population parameters and in stock managementICES Journal of Marine Science, 1995
- Influence of Age-Selective Surveys on the Reliability of Stock Synthesis AssessmentsCanadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 1993
- Variable Natural Mortality Rates Inflate Variance of Recruitments Estimated from Virtual Population Analysis (VPA)Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 1992
- A Solution of the Catch EquationJournal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada, 1965