Efficacy of swallowing rehabilitative therapies for adults with dysphagia: a network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
Authors:
- 23 October 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in GeroScience
- Vol. 47 (2) , 2047-2065
Abstract
Dysphagia leads to poor swallowing function and high risk of aspiration; swallowing rehabilitative therapies including jaw exercises, tongue exercises, chin tuck against resistance (CTAR), Shaker exercises, effortful swallow training (EST), traditional dysphagia therapy (TDT), and respiratory muscle training (RMT) including inspiratory muscle strength training (IMST) and expiratory muscle strength training (EMST) are a crucial part of dysphagia rehabilitation. However, limited evidence exists on the comparative efficacy of swallowing rehabilitative therapies in adults with dysphagia. This is the first network meta-analysis (NMA) to investigate the comparative efficacy of swallowing rehabilitative therapies for adults with dysphagia. Web of Science, Embase, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, and PubMed were comprehensively searched until September, 2024. The Frequentist NMA model was performed in R-Software presenting standardized mean differences with corresponding 95% confidence interval (95% CI) for swallowing function and aspiration. Cochrane Q, τ2, and I2 statistics estimated heterogeneity and full design-by-treatment interaction random-effects and node-splitting models determined transitivity. Ranking of the swallowing rehabilitative therapies used the netrank function. The search yielded 7697 studies from which 25 randomized controlled trials with 1020 adults with dysphagia were included. The study findings revealed that CTAR + TDT (SMD = 3.44 [95% CI 2.42, 4.47]), EMST + TDT (SMD = 2.92 [95% CI 1.59, 4.25]), Shaker + TDT (SMD = 2.83 [95% CI 1.81, 3.84]), JE + TDT (SMD = 2.52 [95% CI 1.21, 3.83]), TE + TDT (SMD = 2.19 [95% CI 1.26, 3.12]), RMT + TDT (SMD = 2.14 [95% CI 1.36, 2.93]), and TDT (SMD = 1.92 [95% CI 1.42, 2.42]) showed very-large to huge effect in improving swallowing function. CTAR + TDT (0.93) demonstrated superior improvements for better swallowing function. Additionally, CTAR + TDT (SMD = − 1.82 [95% CI − 2.89, − 0.75]), Shaker + TDT (SMD = − 1.32 [95% CI − 2.36, − 0.27]), EMST (SMD = − 1.23 [95% CI, − 2.01, − 0.45]), and EMST + TDT (SMD = − 1.10 [95% CI − 2.15, − 0.04]) revealed very-large to large effect in preventing aspiration. CTAR + TDT (0.96) and Shaker + TDT (0.76) demonstrated superior improvements for reduced aspiration. The combination of swallowing rehabilitative therapies including CTAR + TDT and Shaker + TDT offers a more comprehensive approach for dysphagia management in adults. Study registration is PROSPERO: CRD42022321345.Keywords
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Treatment with head-lift exercise in head and neck cancer patients with dysphagia: results from a randomized, controlled trial with flexible endoscopic evaluation of swallowing (FEES)Supportive Care in Cancer, 2022
- The effect of the Shaker head‐lift exercise on swallowing function following treatment for head and neck cancer: Results from a randomized, controlled trial with videofluoroscopic evaluationHead & Neck, 2022
- Swallowing exercises for head and neck cancer patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized control trialsInternational Journal of Nursing Studies, 2021
- Quality of life in tongue cancer treated patients before and after speech therapy: a randomized clinical trialBrazilian Journal of Otorhinolaryngology, 2020
- Post-stroke Dysphagia: Recent Insights and Unanswered QuestionsCurrent Neurology and Neuroscience Reports, 2020
- Swallowing therapy for dysphagia in acute and subacute strokeCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2018
- Effects of a swallowing exercise education program on dysphagia-specific health-related quality of life in oral cavity cancer patients post-treatment: a randomized controlled trialSupportive Care in Cancer, 2018
- Clinical Evaluation of Adults2016
- Prophylactic Swallowing Exercises in Patients With Head and Neck Cancer Undergoing ChemoradiationA Randomized TrialProphylactic Exercises in HNCJAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery, 2012
- Surface Electromyographic Activity of the Submental Muscles During Swallow and Expiratory Pressure Threshold Training TasksDysphagia, 2007