Comparing paper Letters in addition to Emailed Audit and feedback in Refining Asthma treatment to Improve clinical and environmental Results in primary care through a cluster randomised controlled trial: the CLEAR AIR study
Open Access
- 17 April 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Open Respiratory Research
- Vol. 13 (1) , e003601
Abstract
Background: Suboptimal use of preventer inhalers and salbutamol reliever overprescribing are associated with preventable asthma deaths and are a major source of primary care carbon emissions. Audit and feedback produces modest behaviour change by assessing clinical performance and delivering feedback to encourage improvement. Although feedback is increasingly delivered digitally, clinicians may respond more to additional printed feedback reports. We evaluated whether combined digital and paper feedback was more effective than digital-only feedback in promoting safer and greener asthma prescribing at the practice level. Methods: In this parallel, cluster randomised controlled trial, all 273 primary care practices in West Yorkshire were assigned within their primary care network clusters by stratified, permuted block randomisation to receive seven bimonthly reports on asthma prescribing either in ‘digital and paper’ (intervention) or ‘digital-only’ (control) formats. The primary outcome was the proportion of preventer inhalers prescribed in pressurised metred-dose devices due to their high carbon footprint. Intervention group allocation was concealed. The intention-to-treat population was analysed and adjusted for both potential confounders and preintervention achievement. Results: Final analysis assessed 270 practices in 26 clusters per arm due to practice mergers within the control group. There was no significant difference between the intervention groups based on change in the primary outcome (intervention—0.15%; control—0.19%; risk ratio—1.00; 95% CI 0.98 to 1.03) nor any secondary outcome. Analysis of both interventions combined showed a background trend of mixed improvement following feedback. Conclusions: There was no evidence that combined paper and digital feedback was more effective than digital-only feedback, despite the background of mixed improvements following both interventions. Challenges remain to understanding the barriers to influencing the prescribing of preventer inhalers and transitioning inhaler devices towards low-carbon ‘green’ alternatives; however, this study demonstrated the value of an efficient ‘real-world’ trial embedded within an existing quality improvement initiative. Trial registration number: NCT05761873 .Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute for Health and Care Research (ACF-2020-02-004)
- National Institute for Health Research Applied Research Collaboration Yorkshire and Humber (NIHR 200166)
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating inhaler technique, patient preferences and opportunities for improvement in hospitals in the UKFuture Healthcare Journal, 2024
- Reading comprehension on handheld devices versus on paper: A narrative review and meta-analysis of the medium effect and its moderators.Journal of Educational Psychology, 2024
- Health information technology and digital innovation for national learning health and care systemsThe Lancet Digital Health, 2021
- Asthma-Related Health Outcomes Associated with Short-Acting β2-Agonist Inhaler Use: An Observational UK Study as Part of the SABINA Global ProgramAdvances in Therapy, 2020
- Social media, texting, and personality: A test of the shallowing hypothesisPersonality and Individual Differences, 2017
- Practice makes perfect: self-reported adherence a positive marker of inhaler technique maintenancenpj Primary Care Respiratory Medicine, 2017
- Growing Literature, Stagnant Science? Systematic Review, Meta-Regression and Cumulative Analysis of Audit and Feedback Interventions in Health CareJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2014
- Retail sales of inhalation devices in European countries: So much for a global policyRespiratory Medicine, 2011
- Low-Dose Inhaled Corticosteroids and the Prevention of Death from AsthmaNew England Journal of Medicine, 2000
- Bronchodilator tolerance and rebound bronchoconstriction during regular inhaled β -agonist treatmentRespiratory Medicine, 2000