On the Evaluation of Discrepant Scientific Data with Unrecognized Errors

Authors:

Abstract
When n measurements and/or computations of the same (unknown) quantity μ yield data points xj with corresponding standard deviations (uncertainties) σj such that the distances |xj – xk| between any two data points are smaller than or comparable to the sum (σj + σk) of their respective uncertainties, the respective data points are considered to be consistent or to agree within error bars. However, when the distances |xj – xk| are larger than (σj + σk), the respective data are considered to be inconsistent or discrepant. Inconsistencies can be caused by unrecognized or ill-corrected experimental effects (e.g., background corrections, dead time of the counting electronics, instrumental resolution, sample impurities, calibration errors). Although there is a nonzero probability that genuinely discrepant data could occur (for example, for a Gaussian sampling distribution with standard deviation σ, the probability that two equally precise measurements would be separated by more than 2σ is erfc(1) ≃ 0.157...

This publication has 2 references indexed in Scilit: