The influence of macroinvertebrate abundance on the assessment of freshwater quality in The Netherlands
Authors:
- Kevin K. BeentjesKBKevin K. Beentjes
- Arjen G. C. L. SpeksnijderASArjen G. C. L. Speksnijder
- Menno SchilthuizenMSMenno Schilthuizen
- Bartholomeus E.M. SchaubBSBartholomeus E.M. Schaub
- Berry B. van der HoornBHBerry B. van der Hoorn
Open Access
- 12 October 2018
- journal article
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Metabarcoding and Metagenomics
- Vol. 2, e26744
Abstract
The use of molecular tools for the detection and identification of invertebrate species enables the development of more easily standardisable inventories of biological elements for water quality assessments, as it circumvents human-based bias and errors in species identifications. Current Ecological Quality Ratio (EQR) assessments methods, however, often rely on abundance data. Translating metabarcoding sequence data into biomass or specimen abundances has proven difficult, as PCR amplification bias due to primer mismatching often provides skewed proportions of read abundances. While some potential solutions have been proposed in previous research, we instead looked at the necessity of abundance data in EQR assessments. In this study, we used historical monitoring data from natural (lakes, rivers and streams) and artificial (ditches and canals) water bodies to assess the impact of species abundances on the EQR scores for macroinvertebrates in the Water Framework Directive (WFD) monitoring programme of The Netherlands. By removing all the abundance data from the taxon observations, we simulated presence/absence-based monitoring, for which EQRs were calculated according to traditional methods. Our results showed a strong correlation between abundance-based and presence/absence-based EQRs. EQR scores were generally higher without abundances (75.8% of all samples), which resulted in 9.1% of samples being assigned to a higher quality class. The majority of the samples (89.7%) were assigned to the same quality class in both cases. These results are valuable for the incorporation of presence/absence metabarcoding data into water quality assessment methodology, potentially eliminating the need to translate metabarcoding data into biomass or absolute specimen counts for EQR assessments.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Adapting metabarcoding-based benthic biomonitoring into routine marine ecological status assessment networksEcological Indicators, 2018
- DNA metabarcoding reveals the complex and hidden responses of chironomids to multiple stressorsEnvironmental Sciences Europe, 2018
- Testing the potential of a ribosomal 16S marker for DNA metabarcoding of insectsPeerJ, 2016
- Can DNA-Based Ecosystem Assessments Quantify Species Abundance? Testing Primer Bias and Biomass—Sequence Relationships with an Innovative Metabarcoding ProtocolPLOS ONE, 2015
- Environmental Status Assessment Using DNA Metabarcoding: Towards a Genetics Based Marine Biotic Index (gAMBI)PLOS ONE, 2014
- Quantifying sequence proportions in a DNA‐based diet study using Ion Torrent amplicon sequencing: which counts count?Molecular Ecology Resources, 2013
- Environmental monitoring using next generation sequencing: rapid identification of macroinvertebrate bioindicator speciesFrontiers in Zoology, 2013
- Three hundred ways to assess Europe's surface waters: An almost complete overview of biological methods to implement the Water Framework DirectiveEcological Indicators, 2012
- Quantifying microbial communities with 454 pyrosequencing: does read abundance count?Molecular Ecology, 2010
- Errors and uncertainty in bioassessment methods – major results and conclusions from the STAR project and their application using STARBUGSHydrobiologia, 2006