Discrepancies between self-reported medication in adherence and indirect measurement adherence among patients undergoing antiretroviral therapy: a systematic review
Open Access
- 5 July 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Infectious Diseases of Poverty
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-13
Abstract
Background: Given the critical importance of medication adherence in HIV/AIDS treatment, this study aims to compare medication adherence measured by self-report (SR) and indirect measurement among antiretroviral therapy (ART) patients, exploring the differences of adherence results measured by different tools. Methods: We systematically searched PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Library to identify all relevant literature published up to November 22, 2023, without language restrictions, reporting adherence to ART measured by both SR and indirect measurement methods, while also analyzing individual and group adherence separately. Discrepancies between SR and indirect measurement results were assessed using the Mann–Whitney U test or Wilcoxon signed-rank test, with correlations evaluated using the Pearson correlation coefficient. Following one-to-one comparisons, meta-epidemiological one-step analysis was conducted, and network meta-analysis techniques were applied to compare results obtained through specific adherence assessment tools reported in the identified articles. Results: The analysis encompassed 65 original studies involving 13,667 HIV/AIDS patients, leading to 112 one-to-one comparisons between SR and indirect measurement tools. Statistically significant differences were observed between SR and indirect measurement tools regarding both individual and group adherence (P < 0.05), with Pearson correlation coefficients of 0.843 for individual adherence and 0.684 for group adherence. During meta-epidemiological one-step analysis, SR-measured adherence was determined to be 3.94% (95% CI: -4.48–13.44%) higher for individual adherence and 16.14% (95% CI: 0.81–18.84%) higher for group adherence compared to indirectly measured results. Subgroup analysis indicated that factors such as the year of reporting and geographic region appeared to influence the discrepancies between SR and indirect measurements. Furthermore, network meta-analysis revealed that for both individual and group adherence, the results obtained from most SR and indirect measurement tools were higher than those from electronic monitoring devices, with some demonstrating statistical significance (P < 0.05). Conclusions: The findings underscored the complexity of accurately measuring medication adherence among ART patients. Significant variability was observed across studies, with self-report methods showing a significant tendency towards overestimation. Year of reporting, geographic region, and adherence measurement tools appeared to influence the differences between SR and indirect measurements. Future research should focus on developing and validating integrated adherence measurements that can combine SR data with indirect measures to achieve a more comprehensive understanding of adherence behaviors. GraphicalKeywords
Funding Information
- Innovative Research Group Project of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (72074161, 81602935)
- Sichuan Provincial Science and Technology Support Program (2022YFS0229, 2022YFS0641)
- Liangshan Prefecture Science and Technology Bureau Program (23ZDYF0025)
- HIV and Drug Abuse Prevention Research Ethics Training Institute, Fordham University (23ZDYF0112)
This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- Accuracy of measures for antiretroviral adherence in people living with HIVCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2022
- Universal test and treat is not associated with sub‐optimal antiretroviral therapy adherence in rural South Africa: the ANRS 12249 TasP trialJournal of the International AIDS Society, 2018
- Validation of a New Three-Item Self-Report Measure for Medication AdherenceAIDS and Behavior, 2016
- A Proposal for Quality Standards for Measuring Medication Adherence in ResearchAIDS and Behavior, 2012
- Measuring Adherence to Antiretroviral Treatment: The Role of Pharmacy Records of Drug WithdrawalsAIDS and Behavior, 2012
- Real-Time Adherence Monitoring for HIV Antiretroviral TherapyAIDS and Behavior, 2010
- Longitudinal Antiretroviral Adherence in HIV+ Ugandan Parents and Their Children Initiating HAART in the MTCT-Plus Family Treatment Model: Role of Depression in Declining Adherence Over TimeAIDS and Behavior, 2009
- Adherence to HAART therapy measured by electronic monitoring in newly diagnosed HIV patients in BotswanaEuropean Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 2007
- Optimal Recall Period and Response Task for Self-Reported HIV Medication AdherenceAIDS and Behavior, 2007
- Measurement of anticonvulsant adherence behaviour in the community using a medication events monitoring system (MEMS)Health Care Analysis, 1998