Referring and Specialist Physician Gender and Specialist Billing

Authors:

Abstract
Gender pay inequity in medicine has been documented across jurisdictions, with female physicians earning consistently less than male physicians.1-14 One important mechanism discussed in the literature is specialist income and the role of gender-based referral bias. Anecdotal evidence has been documented about gender-based referral biases leading to significant pay gaps, including referrals of lower quality and revenue.15 Female specialists have been reported to perform less complex cases and work fewer days per period than males.16-18 A longitudinal study from Ontario, Canada, found that female surgeons received fewer referrals than male surgeons throughout their career pathway irrespective of experience and that this did not self-correct over time.19 Studies in the US have found evidence that physicians tend to refer to specialists of the same gender.20,21 One study found that female surgeons experienced more severe repercussions from referring physicians after negative surgical outcomes than male surgeons (eg, a patient death was associated with fewer and lower-revenue referrals for female surgeons) and that a negative experience with 1 female physician tended to reduce the likelihood of new referrals to other female surgeons within the same specialty.22 Types of gender bias hypothesized to mediate referral differences include bias from peers, hospital staff, surgical leadership, and patients.23