Silviculture for Deer and Timber: A Multiple-Use Policy Analysis Reveals Important Implementation Barriers
Open Access
Abstract
Policies that attempt to balance timber production with non-market values that forests provide are common across the United States. Such is the case in northern Maine, USA, where management of critical areas of mature softwood-dominated forest are regulated through the State’s primary wildlife management agency. We use a case study approach with qualitative and quantitative analyses to understand the persistent difficulties encountered by both forest and wildlife managers when implementing this policy. Interviews with foresters and wildlife biologists established the management parameters, and simulated management scenarios compared forest management outcomes with respect to both financial and wildlife habitat provision goals. The model results indicated that there are opportunities for comparable revenues within regulated habitat areas as without, although the returns varied due to legacy of previous management and species composition. More importantly, the interviews revealed that differing habitat metrics used by foresters and biologists are a barrier to communication and management planning, and thus also a barrier to effective policy implementation. We close with thoughts on the applicability of both the methods and results to other situations where an understanding of multiple-use forest policy implementation is desired.Keywords
Funding Information
- USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, McIntire Stennis (1005416, 1011463)
- Cooperative Forestry Research Unit, University of Maine (NA)
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Management of Eucalyptus plantations influences small mammal density: Evidence from Southern EuropeForest Ecology and Management, 2017
- Evaluating carbon storage, timber harvest, and habitat possibilities for a Western Cascades (USA) forest landscapeEcological Applications, 2016
- Canada lynx occurrence and forest management in the Acadian ForestThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2013
- First decadal response to treatment in a disturbance-based silviculture experiment in MaineForest Ecology and Management, 2011
- Winter conditions in eastern hemlock and mixed-hardwood deer wintering areas of VermontCanadian Journal of Forest Research, 2007
- Within-yard habitat use by white-tailed deer at varying winter severityForest Ecology and Management, 2003
- Economic analysis of slash pine forest carbon sequestration in the southern U. S.Journal of Forest Economics, 2002
- Seasonal Movements and Home Ranges of White-Tailed Deer in the AdirondacksThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 1985
- Characteristics of Hemlock Stands Related to Deer Use in East-Central OntarioJournal of Applied Ecology, 1980
- Energy Conservation by White‐Tailed Deer in the WinterEcology, 1976