The two-thumb is superior to the two-finger method for administering chest compressions in a manikin model of neonatal resuscitation
Authors:
- 16 September 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood - Fetal and Neonatal Edition
- Vol. 96 (2) , F99-F101
Abstract
Background Current neonatal guidelines endorse both the two-thumb and the two-finger techniques for performing chest compressions. It remains unclear whether one method is superior to the other in achieving consistent depth. Objective To compare the compression depth, variability, rate and finger placement of the two-thumb and two-finger techniques using a compression to ventilation (CV) ratio of 3:1. Methods 25 subjects (physicians and neonatal nurses) participated with compressions performed on a manikin. Subjects were video recorded. Evaluations included continuous compression administered for 60 s, followed by 2 min of compressions using a 3:1 CV ratio for each of the two techniques. Results Depth during 60 s of uninterrupted compressions was greater for the two-thumb than the two-finger technique (27.2±5.7 vs 22.1±4.6 mm; p=0.0008), variability was less (6.7%±3.2% vs 9.0%±2.8%; p=0.002) and rate was comparable (118±22 vs 116±24 compressions/min). With a 3:1 CV ratio, depth was greater for the two-thumb compared to the two-finger method (29±5.4 vs 23.7±5.8 mm; p=0.0009), variability was less (6.1%±2.9% vs 9.8%±3.1%; p=0.00002) and rate was comparable (192±26 vs 197±31 compressions/2 min). Correct positioning was accomplished more often with the two-thumb than the two-finger technique (21/25 vs 3/25; p=0.0005). Conclusions The two-thumb technique is superior to the two-finger technique, achieving greater depth and less variability with each compression. The two-finger technique was incorrectly applied in most cases and deviations in technique may have contributed to the significant differences in depth.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Use and Efficacy of Endotracheal Versus Intravenous Epinephrine During Neonatal Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Delivery RoomPediatrics, 2006
- Two‐thumb vs Two‐finger Chest Compression in an Infant Model of Prolonged Cardiopulmonary ResuscitationAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2000
- Comparison of a two-finger versus two-thumb method for chest compressions by healthcare providers in an infant mechanical modelResuscitation, 2000
- A randomized, controlled trial of two-thumb vs two-finger chest compression in a swine infant model of cardiac arrestPrehospital Emergency Care, 1997
- Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Delivery RoomArchives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 1995
- Two-thumb versus two-finger chest compression during CPR in a swine infant model of cardiac arrestAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 1993
- Closed Chest Cardiac Massage in the Newborn InfantPediatrics, 1988
- Cardiac Output and Other Hemodynamic Variables during External Cardiac Massage in ManNew England Journal of Medicine, 1963
- Cardiac massage in the newborn infant through the intact chestAmerican Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 1962