Healthcare providers consistently overestimate the diagnostic probability of ventilator-associated pneumonia
Open Access
- 23 June 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology
- Vol. 44 (12) , 1927-1931
Abstract
Objective: To assess the accuracy of provider estimates of ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) diagnostic probability in various clinical scenarios.Design: We conducted a clinical vignette-based survey of intensive care unit (ICU) physicians to evaluate provider estimates of VAP diagnostic probability before and after isolated cardinal VAP clinical changes and VAP diagnostic test results. Responses were used to calculate imputed diagnostic likelihood ratios (LRs), which were compared to evidence-based LRs.Setting: Michigan Medicine University Hospital, a tertiary-care center.Participants: This study included 133 ICU clinical faculty and house staff.Results: Provider estimates of VAP diagnostic probability were consistently higher than evidence-based diagnostic probabilities. Similarly, imputed LRs from provider-estimated diagnostic probabilities were consistently higher than evidence-based LRs. These differences were most notable for positive bronchoalveolar lavage culture (provider-estimated LR 5.7 vs evidence-based LR 1.4; P < .01), chest radiograph with air bronchogram (provider-estimated LR 6.0 vs evidence-based LR 3.6; P < .01), and isolated purulent endotracheal secretions (provider-estimated LR 1.6 vs evidence-based LR 0.8; P < .01). Attending physicians and infectious disease physicians were more accurate in their LR estimates than trainees (P = .04) and non-ID physicians (P = .03).Conclusions: Physicians routinely overestimated the diagnostic probability of VAP as well as the positive LRs of isolated cardinal VAP clinical changes and VAP diagnostic test results. Diagnostic stewardship initiatives, including educational outreach and clinical decision support systems, may be useful adjuncts in minimizing VAP overdiagnosis and ICU antibiotic overuse.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Educational intervention to reduce treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria in long-term careBMJ Open Quality, 2018
- Animal-assisted intervention in the ICU: a tool for humanizationCritical Care, 2018
- Optimizing Test Utilization in the Clinical Microbiology Laboratory: Tools and OpportunitiesJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2017
- Association of Adverse Events With Antibiotic Use in Hospitalized PatientsJAMA Internal Medicine, 2017
- Understanding Decision Making in Critical CareClinical Medicine & Research, 2015
- How well do health professionals interpret diagnostic information? A systematic reviewBMJ Open, 2015
- Effectiveness of an Antimicrobial Stewardship Approach for Urinary Catheter–Associated Asymptomatic BacteriuriaJAMA Internal Medicine, 2015
- Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia: Overdiagnosis and Treatment Are Common in Medical and Surgical Intensive Care UnitsInfection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, 2014
- Does This Patient Have Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia?JAMA, 2007
- Why are antibiotics prescribed for asymptomatic bacteriuria in institutionalized elderly people? A qualitative study of physicians' and nurses' perceptions.2000