Isotopic Differentiation (δ18OPO4) of Inorganic Phosphorus among Organic Wastes for Nutrient Runoff Tracing Studies: A Summary of the Literature with Refinement of Livestock Estimates for Grand Lake St. Marys Watershed (Ohio)
Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Pollutants
- Vol. 4 (3) , 316-323
Abstract
The use of stable isotopes, specifically δ18OPO4 ratios, in differentiating potential sources of inorganic phosphorus (e.g., wastewater, septic, wild animals, domesticated animals, livestock, substrates, or commercial fertilizers) to watersheds is a growing field. This method produces data that, used in conjunction with statistical mixing models, enables a better understanding of contributing sources of runoff. However, given the recent development of this research area there are obvious limitations that have arisen, due in large part to the limited available reference data to compare water samples. Here, we attempt to expand the availability of reference samples by applying stable isotope methods to three types of common agricultural manures: poultry, dairy, and swine. We also aim to concatenate the organic waste literature on this topic, creating a more robust comparison database for future study and application in phosphorus source partitioning research. Among our samples, δ18OPO4 ratios for poultry were considerably elevated compared to dairy and swine manures (values of 18.5‰, 16.5‰, and 17.9‰, respectively). Extending this to other published ratios of δ18OPO4 from various types of waste products (e.g., septic, wastewater, livestock, other animals), a total range from 8.7‰ to 23.1‰ emerged (with existing poultry manure samples also ranking among the highest overall). Variation among samples in the larger dataset demonstrates the need for a further compilation of δ18OPO4 ratios for various types of waste, especially specific to geographic regions and watershed scales. With an increased sample size, the statistical strength associated with these methods would greatly improve.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ohio Department of Higher Education (671409)
- Wright State University’s Women in Science Giving Circle (671409)
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploring long-term trends in microcystin toxin values associated with persistent harmful algal blooms in Grand Lake St MarysHarmful Algae, 2023
- Phosphate distribution and sources in the waters of Huangbai River, China: using oxygen isotope composition of phosphate as a tracerEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2021
- Evaluating management options to reduce Lake Erie algal blooms using an ensemble of watershed modelsJournal of Environmental Management, 2021
- Evaluating the stable isotopic composition of phosphate oxygen as a tracer of phosphorus from waste water treatment worksApplied Geochemistry, 2018
- Assessing the use of δ18O in phosphate as a tracer for catchment phosphorus sourcesScience of The Total Environment, 2017
- Phosphate stable oxygen isotope variability within a temperate agricultural soilGeoderma, 2017
- Sustainable management of Great Lakes watersheds dominated by agricultural land useJournal of Great Lakes Research, 2016
- Health impacts from cyanobacteria harmful algae blooms: Implications for the North American Great LakesHarmful Algae, 2016
- Evaluation of targeting methods for implementation of best management practices in the Saginaw River WatershedJournal of Environmental Management, 2012
- Oxygen isotopes of phosphate and the origin of island apatite depositsEarth and Planetary Science Letters, 1992