What is the proposed role of research evidence in England’s ‘self-improving’ school system?
Author:
- 4 July 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Oxford Review of Education
- Vol. 43 (4) , 433-446
Abstract
This article examines the English government’s vision for how research is proposed to lead to improvements in the system in the context of a school-led, self-improving system and rapid and sweeping legislative reforms. The debate about the role of research in the teaching profession has been sharpened by a large consultation effort in the academic community. The BERA-RSA inquiry suggests an empowering vision for teachers where research engagement informs practice and a role for schools in providing a ‘research-rich environment’. However, the government’s proposals offer a rather less empowering vision. The author of the paper contrasts a version of research-informed teaching and leadership with one where teachers are supposed to follow and be led by the evidence. The government’s education policy, especially as set out in the 2016 White Paper ‘Educational Excellence Everywhere’ is analysed in relation to this position. Analysis of statements from the document are shown in the paper, and contextualised with examples from the English school system. The extent to which teacher agency is promoted through research evidence is explored. The article concludes that the government’s over emphasis on a ‘what works’/‘evidence-based practice’ model is unhelpful in achieving an improved education system. Suggestions for the role of universities and the College of Teaching in promoting research-informed practice are given.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Instructional leadership: toward a contextualised knowledge creation modelSchool Leadership & Management, 2012
- Learning about networked learning communitiesSchool Effectiveness and School Improvement, 2010
- WHY “WHAT WORKS” WON’T WORK: EVIDENCE‐BASED PRACTICE AND THE DEMOCRATIC DEFICIT IN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHEducational Theory, 2007
- Teachers' Engagement in and with Research: supporting integrity and creativity in teachingFORUM, 2006
- What works to promote evidence-based practice? A cross-sector reviewEvidence & Policy, 2005
- School self‐evaluation and the role of a critical friendCambridge Journal of Education, 2005
- Evidence-led professioanl creativity: a perspective from the general teaching council for EnglandEducational Action Research, 2004
- Is it ‘what works’ that matters? Evaluation and evidence‐based policy‐makingResearch Papers in Education, 2003
- In Defence of Ideas, or Why 'What Works' is Not EnoughBritish Journal of Sociology of Education, 2000
- Have We Learned Anything New About the Use of Evaluation?American Journal of Evaluation, 1998