Educational Reforms can Reproduce Societal Inequities: A Case Study
Authors:
- James Joseph ScheurichJSJames Joseph Scheurich
- Michael ImberMIMichael Imber
- 1 August 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Educational Administration Quarterly
- Vol. 27 (3) , 297-320
Abstract
Although critical theorists in educational administration have recently contended that administrative practices play an important role in the reproduction of societal inequities, little research has been done to show how this actually occurs in schools. This article addresses that lack by reporting a case study illustrating how one school district's reform efforts replicate the unequal distribution of knowledge, power, and resources by race and class that often occurs in society. The article begins with a critical discussion of the three dominant paradigms in educational organization change theory -functionalism, culturalism, and critical theory -and ends with practical suggestions about how the school district could have more equitably proceeded with its reform efforts.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Toward A Critical Constructivist Approach to School Administration: Invisibility, Legitimation, and the Study of Non-EventsEducational Administration Quarterly, 1990
- Some Missing Elements in the Educational Reform MovementEducational Administration Quarterly, 1988
- Recent State Education Reform in the United States: Looking Backward and ForwardEducational Administration Quarterly, 1988
- Educational Reform: Rhetoric, Ritual, and Social InterestEducational Theory, 1988
- The Male/Female Salary Differential for School Administrators: Implications for Career Patterns and Placement of WomenEducational Administration Quarterly, 1988
- Corporate Culture, Schooling, and Educational AdministrationEducational Administration Quarterly, 1987
- The Local School District Superintendency: A Puzzling Administrative RoleEducational Administration Quarterly, 1987
- CRITICAL THEORY AND EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATIONJournal of Educational Administration, 1987
- Issues of validity in openly ideological research: Between a rock and a soft placeInterchange, 1986
- Educational Administration, the Sociology of Science, and the Management of KnowledgeEducational Administration Quarterly, 1980