Paradoxical effects of praise and criticism: Social, dimensional and temporal comparisons
Author:
- 1 June 2005
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 75 (2) , 275-295
Abstract
Background. When developing a domain‐specific academic self‐concept, students are not restricted to social comparisons; they may also make temporal or dimensional comparisons. Aims. The main purpose of this study was to examine whether these different types of comparison trigger paradoxical effects of praise and criticism in the sense described by . University students participated in Study 1 ( N =120) and Study 4 ( N =83). The Study 2 sample consisted of 180 seventh to ninth grade students, and Study 3 investigated paradoxical effects with a sample of 130 elementary school students. Methods. Participants were presented with vignettes describing the results of 2 students (social comparison condition) versus 1 student in 2 subjects (dimensional comparison) versus 1 student in 2 subsequent tests (temporal comparison). In all cases, the results were identical. Participants were then informed about a teacher's response to these results (praise vs. criticism vs. neutral response), and were asked to estimate the ability of the 2 stimulus persons. Results. Study 1 and Study 2 revealed that dimensional, as well as social, comparisons following praise and criticism elicit paradoxical effects of perceived ability, reflected in corresponding estimations of student effort and teacher expectancies. There were no paradoxical effects following temporal comparisons. Study 3 did not reveal any paradoxical effects, thereby supporting the assumption that the occurrence of such effects depends on the level of cognitive development. Study 4 showed that the paradoxical effects found in Study 1 and 2 occur even when the sanctioned and the neutral achievement are presented independently. Conclusions. Dimensional comparisons, which have been largely overlooked in the past, play a major role in ability inferences.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessment and Classroom LearningAssessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 1998
- Coursework Selection: Relations to Academic Self-Concept and AchievementAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1997
- Conceptions of Ability and the Interpretation of Praise, Blame, and Material RewardsThe Journal of Experimental Education, 1996
- Influences of internal and external frames of reference on the formation of math and English self-concepts.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1990
- Theory and research concerning social comparisons of personal attributes.Psychological Bulletin, 1989
- Developmental study of praise and blame as attributional cues.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1987
- Verbal and Math Self-Concepts: An Internal/External Frame of Reference ModelAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1986
- Teacher Praise: A Functional AnalysisReview of Educational Research, 1981
- Effort: The double-edged sword in school achievement.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1979
- A Theory of Social Comparison ProcessesHuman Relations, 1954