Nature or Nurture? A Re-examination of Sloboda and Howe's (1991) Interview Study on Talent Development in Music
Author:
- 1 April 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Psychology of Music
- Vol. 27 (1) , 38-51
Abstract
The core of this text will consist of a re-examination of data gathered by Sloboda and Howe (1991) through interviews with young students in a specialist music school. I will demonstrate that these authors, guided by a strict environmentalist framework, incorrectly interpreted their data because they did not acknowledge the role of musical giftedness as a significant determinant of the large differences observed in their sample between exceptional and average students. I intend to show that their results cannot be correctly interpreted without introducing musical aptitudes as a significant causal factor. Since the authors did not specify in their text what theoretical framework guided their study, my description of their position as strict environmentalism is inferred from other publications by them (e.g. Sloboda, Davidson and Howe, 1994; Howe, Davidson and Sloboda, 1998).Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Proposal for Subcategories Within Gifted or Talented PopulationsGifted Child Quarterly, 1998
- From giftedness to talent: A developmental model and its impact on the language of the fieldRoeper Review, 1995
- Effects of Musical Aptitude, Academic Ability, Music Experience, and Motivation on Aural SkillsJournal of Research in Music Education, 1994
- The Best-Laid PlansEducational Researcher, 1993
- Relationships Among Parental Involvement, Music Aptitude, and Musical Achievement of Instrumental Music StudentsJournal of Research in Music Education, 1992
- Biographical Precursors of Musical Excellence: An Interview StudyPsychology of Music, 1991
- Development and Validation of the Home Musical Environment Scale for Use at the Early Elementary LevelPsychology of Music, 1985
- Effects of Certain Lateral Dominance Traits, Music Aptitude, and Sex Differences with Instrumental Music AchievementJournal of Research in Music Education, 1978
- The Role of Musical Aptitude, Intelligence, and Academic Achievement in Predicting the Musical Attainment of Elementary Instrumental Music StudentsJournal of Research in Music Education, 1971
- A Pilot Study to Investigate the Constructs of Musical AptitudeJournal of Research in Music Education, 1965