A Head-to-head Comparison between SurgiMend and Epiflex in 127 Breast Reconstructions
Open Access
- 1 June 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery - Global Open
- Vol. 3 (6) , e439
Abstract
Background: The use of acellular dermal matrices (ADM) has become a widely used option in breast reconstruction. A great deal of literature is available, totaling over 2400 ADM reconstructions. Nonetheless, head-to-head comparisons between SurgiMend and Epiflex are not yet reported. In fact, this is the first clinical data report on the use of Epiflex. This work will, therefore, compare postoperative complication rates and costs for these ADMs. Methods: This analysis is a retrospective review of a single surgeon’s 6-year experience with both SurgiMend—an acellular bovine dermal collagen matrix for soft-tissue reconstruction and Epiflex—a decellularized human skin tissue from 2008 to 2013. Results: One hundred patients had a total of 127 implant-based reconstructions using SurgiMend (64 cases; 50.4%) or Epiflex (63 cases; 49.6%). Gross complication rates were 11.1% for SurgiMend and 40.6% for Epiflex including hematoma, postoperative skin irritation, infection, necrosis, and revision surgery. The most common complication was postoperative red breast syndrome. Severe complications requiring revision surgery were significantly increased in patients treated with Epiflex (12.5%) compared with SurgiMend (4.8%). Conclusions: This retrospective analysis favors the use of SurgiMend over Epiflex because of significantly lower gross complication rates. Severe complication rates are comparable with those reported in literature for both products. Although results promote the use of SurgiMend, the single surgeon retrospective nature of this work limits its clinical impact.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- TiLoop® Bra mesh used for immediate breast reconstruction: comparison of retropectoral and subcutaneous implant placement in a prospective single-institution seriesEuropean Journal of Plastic Surgery, 2014
- Biological Matrices and Synthetic Meshes Used in Implant-based Breast Reconstruction – a Review of Products Available in GermanyGeburtshilfe und Frauenheilkunde, 2013
- Economic Analysis and Review of the Literature on Implant-Based Breast Reconstruction With and Without the Use of the Acellular Dermal MatrixAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2013
- Implant-Based Breast Reconstruction Using a Titanium-Coated Polypropylene Mesh (TiLOOP Bra)Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2013
- 440 Consecutive Immediate, Implant-Based, Single-Surgeon Breast Reconstructions in 281 PatientsPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2013
- Prevention of seroma formation with TissuGlu® surgical adhesive in a canine abdominoplasty model: Long term clinical and histologic studiesJournal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery, 2013
- A Paradigm Shift in U.S. Breast ReconstructionPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2013
- Differentiation of Biologic Scaffold Materials Through Physicomechanical, Thermal, and Enzymatic Degradation TechniquesAnnals of Surgery, 2012
- Acellular Dermis-Assisted Breast ReconstructionAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2008
- Immediate Breast Reconstruction in Two Stages Using Textured, Integrated-Valve Tissue Expanders and Breast ImplantsPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2004